Sorry so slow in getting back to this, I was playing WoW over the weekend :)

Chris Pinkham wrote:

Yeah, I didn't think the User Jobs would take off as much as they have so I
didn't make them as easy to use as the transcoder and commflagging jobs.


User Jobs are awesome! There's a million uses for them, from maintenance to notification. I create a browsable file view of the recordings, a friend of mine has a user job that scp's recordings to his machine at work, someone else logs the completion via email. It's freakin' great.

This isn't necessarily true, there are "Global" settings and "Host" settings
in the backend setup program.


Ah I didn't notice that the two pages in setup were one host, one global.

Since the Auto Commercial Flag default setting is accessible via the
frontend, I think it makes sense to have the User Job defaults settings
be accessible from the frontends also.


Where is the "Auto Commercial Flag" default setting in the frontend? I agree that would be an excellent place to put them too. (Yeah I've used MythTV for 2 years now, I still don't know where all the settings are).

This I'm not sure about. What would be the reasons for making a User Job
run by default for one recording profile but not for another? Are you
thinking nuvexport or something?


Well in my scenario, I'm only symlinking stuff that is from the default and low quality profile. My Live TV and High Quality profiles are too high bitrate to go over my wireless link so I don't confuse myself by running my symlink job on recordings made using them. I can see the possibility that someone running an nuvexport might want something similar, but I'm satisfied with just defaulting jobs globally. If I added it in all places it would start to get confusing how the the backend decides what to do by default, probably ending up like this:
if (job globally defaults to on) and (recording profile job defaults to on)
default to on
else
default to off


So say put it one place but not the other.  Globally might make more sense.

On that note, I originally had a commented-out setting to allow turning
on/off transcoding jobs on a per-scheduled recoring basis, but took that
code back out. This would allow the user to run transcoding for some
shows but not for others that used the same recording profile. Does
anyone see any value in this flexibility?


I wouldn't see any benefit to this. It might be a better solution to allow creation / removal of new recording profiles. You'd then create a new profile like "HD (archival)" that had the transcode option flipped on, which is easier than going through multiple steps in the scheduled recording setup screens. I'm more an advocate of selecting a recording profile that has all my options preset in it though, rather than tweaking each recording schedule's items. It also makes it easier for me to send an email from my cell phone telling my backend to record something, but that's a myth-users post.
_______________________________________________
mythtv-dev mailing list
[email protected]
http://mythtv.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/mythtv-dev

Reply via email to