On Sat, 04 Jun 2005 15:16:03 +0100, Neale Swinnerton wrote:

The Active Format Descriptor (AFD) is set by some broadcasters like ITV1
and CH4 in the UK in their DVB-T streams. This signals what the format
of the video is, and along with the aspect ratio of the video stream and
your display it can resize the video 'better'.

This patch adds support for this to myth. To enable it go to
Utilities/Setup->Settings->TV Settings->Playback and set aspect override
to AFD.

I have no idea if AFD is supported in Aus, but I've been thinking of re-working the aspect ratio override stuff for a while. Here are my thoughts...

Aus DVB broadcasts are usually 16:9, but that is often an already pillarboxed 4:3 image. My TV is 4:3. For many shows you want the aspect override set to 'Fill' to remove the pillarboxing, otherwise you end up with an image that is first pillarboxed remotely, then letterboxed locally. For signals that really are 16:9, you want to switch the aspect ratio override to 'off'. Switching between 'Fill' and 'Off' can require cycling through a whole list of other 'aspect ratio' settings - something that I find a little annoying at times.

It seems that there are really three settings here which are being confused:

i) The aspect ratio of the incoming signal. This is usually correct for DVB in Aus, but I can imagine people wanting to over-ride it. I don't know how often this changes however - it should be set and forget, shouldn't it? ii) The aspect ratio of the display. This should also be set and forget (if it isn't already correct from your X setup). iii) How to handle aspect ratio mismatch when i) and ii) are not equal. This is the setting that I want to change somewhat regularly. I can imagine switching between 'Zoom in' == 'Fill', and 'Zoom out' == 'letterbox/pillarbox'. Is this what AFD is for?

With this arrangement, I could set the 'w' key to just change the last setting. I get a much simpler interface.

Can anyone see any reasons not to split things up this way?

Cheers,

Will           :-}

_______________________________________________
mythtv-dev mailing list
[email protected]
http://mythtv.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/mythtv-dev

Reply via email to