If you live near a coast, you are going to experience bigger storms and loss of 
power more often than someone that lives inland.  If you live in the Himalayas 
you are going to get more snow and cold weather.  Not my problem if you like 
your beach front property.  However I have not seen any major damage to fiber 
based networks and I was a first responder during Hurricane Katrina.  The 
majority of damage was to flooded central offices which is going to happen from 
time to time no matter where you are at.  Overall network reliability has 
increased greatly over the years which is undeniable.  This all just seems very 
alarmist to me.  Also, even if we assume you are correct about ocean levels 
threatening networks (which I don't believe to be even close to the biggest 
threats), what exactly can the NANOG community do about it for you.    There 
are real, live, NOW, threats like the BGP hijackings that have been responded 
to that are real operational responses.

Steven Naslund
Chicago IL


>But the reality is that if you get bigger storm surges, your Internet access 
>will be knocked. You will get loss of power and even if the backbone holds up, 
>the access networks will not. Every time we get a severe flood here in 
>Budapest, power is >knocked out and we are down hard. The general population 
>may not take much comfort in your installation of thousands of miles of fiber. 
>Just a fact.

>

>Regards,

>

>Roderick.

Reply via email to