Why Canada was not elected to UN Security Council three years ago
[http://www.hilltimes.com/sites/hilltimes.com/files/story_image/2013/09/09_shuffle_y-BKBG1SEJfF7Fb8KqOdgZdnnbX1WFoSSZHxOSja6mk,sjjhGiEngWcyTaGrUmdjWlWu8wZTTrazfFHy4dMJLRw.jpg]
Photograph courtesy of the PMO
Foreign policy: How tiresome, smug and un-Canadian is the stolid simplicity of 
the Harper-Baird 'we-won't-go-along-to-get-along' mantra, writes Robert Fowler.
By ROBERT FOWLER<http://www.hilltimes.com/author/Robert%20Fowler> |
Published: Monday, 09/30/2013 12:00 am EDT

http://www.hilltimes.com/opinion-piece/2013/09/30/why-canada-was-not-elected-to-un-security-council-three-years-ago/36050

How tiresome, how smug and-I will argue-how un-Canadian is the stolid 
simplicity of the Harper-Baird "we-won't-go-along-to-get-along" mantra. But it 
is that arrogant, me-first, "I'm all right, Jack, and to hell with you" 
posture, coupled with extravagant insensitivity, which destroyed Canada's bid 
for a seventh term on the Security Council three years ago. Until that changes, 
those attitudes will ensure that Canada is excluded from any important role 
within the community of nations.

The fact is, the pony we had entered in the Security Council lists in the fall 
of 2010 was lame and there was nothing hardworking Canadian diplomats in New 
York and around the world could do to disguise that fact. Three years ago, the 
nations of the world, voting according to their own interests, did not believe 
that they needed more of the Canada they had been getting on the Security 
Council. How preposterous it was to claim that our defeat was a triumph of our 
values over theirs!

Canadian environmental policy was-and remains-a fiasco. Canada had taken strong 
stands in the global effort to combat environmental degradation, beginning in 
Stockholm in 1972, and over the years worked hard to build momentum behind 
efforts to create a global climate treaty. The Montreal Protocol to phase out 
materials that were damaging the ozone layer was a good start.

However daunting, our obligations as a party to the Kyoto Protocol represented 
a formal engagement, and our decision in December 2011 to become the first 
nation to withdraw from Kyoto represented a blow to our international 
reputation from which we have not begun to recover.

And then, only a few months ago, Canada announced its intention to become the 
first (and only) country to withdraw from the "UN Convention to Combat 
Desertification" to which 194 states had become a party following its adoption 
in 1994. Imagine for a moment how those desperately impoverished states 
suffering the daily encroachment of the Sahara felt about Mr. Harper's 
insistence that such efforts were but a "talkfest" and that our annual 
contribution of $350,000 was a waste of money.

For the 37 members of the Alliance of Small Island States, climate change is an 
existential issue. If it isn't fixed, they will be under water. When offered 
the opportunity to vote on Canada's disdain for their concerns, they did so 
with clarity of purpose. Our refusal to understand-let alone empathize 
with-such deeply held views has sorely damaged the reputation of our country.

I have emphasized the extent to which Canada's stand on environmental issues 
has caused much of the world community to lose faith in us, to mistrust our 
words and misconstrue our motives. But rest assured, we have offered the world 
community lots of other reasons not to support us. In the eyes of the 57 
members of the Organization of the Islamic Conference at the UN, the Harper 
government's insistence on an unbalanced "Israel right or wrong" posture which 
countenances no criticism, while characterizing other states in the region with 
thinly veiled disdain, is simply an anathema.

Then there's the Harper government's writing off of Africa (which accounts for 
70 per cent of the Security Council's business), the largest and most diverse 
continent; a billion people in 54 different countries (and votes); a region 
deemed not worthy of interest by our government.

In recent years, our contribution to UN peacekeeping has become statistically 
irrelevant in what is an ever more challenging international security 
environment, the management of which is the Security Council's mandate. 
Canadian military professionalism, integrity and steadfastness are greatly 
missed in UN circles. Indeed, these days Canada is simply absent from the 
discussion of how to better manage international affairs.

These are the areas in which for the first 60 years of the UN's existence 
Canada genuinely punched above its weight. By being an exemplary UN citizen, we 
were able, in six successive decades, to win election to the Security Council, 
despite the fact that the membership of the organization grew four-fold over 
this period. The campaign in the late '90s was hard fought, but I never doubted 
we would prevail. There was then a huge reserve of sympathy and respect for 
Canada and Canadians within the organization. We were seen to be fair but firm, 
balanced and principled, yet always sensitive to the worries and concerns of 
others while being very clear about the promotion and projection of our own 
beliefs and values, and committed to an effective UN. We have, however, 
squandered that fine reputation, and it will not be restored until Canada 
adopts positions on international issues that are seen to be good for the world 
as well as good for Canada.

Robert Fowler was the foreign policy adviser to prime ministers Pierre Trudeau, 
John Turner and Brian Mulroney, deputy minister of National Defence, Canada's 
longest-serving ambassador to the UN, ambassador to Italy, and personal 
representative for Africa of prime ministers Jean Chrétien, Paul Martin and 
Stephen Harper. He retired in 2006 and is a senior fellow at the University of 
Ottawa's Graduate School of Public and International Affairs. This column is 
from the book, The United Nations And Canada What Canada Has Done And Should Be 
Doing At The UN, edited by John Trent.

[email protected]

The Hill Times



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

Native News North
List info{all lists}:
http://nativenewsonline.org/natnews.htm

Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/NatNews-north/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/NatNews-north/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://info.yahoo.com/legal/us/yahoo/utos/terms/

Reply via email to