Alexander Larsson wrote:
Analysis
--------
Unix usernames can contain special characters, but as such there is no need to
escape the username before passing the uri. While escaping, the character ';',
gets substituted with '%3B' and the uri can't be understood by gnome-vfs.
    

There is a very real reason to escape usernames in uris: The username
may contain special symbols. Usernames like [EMAIL PROTECTED] are very common
in many places. Even ; might be allowed in some type of usernames. 

What we should do is allow you to type in the domain like a normal human
in a "domain" field, not force users to learn magic uri semantics to
specify the domain.
  
Yes, for giving domain name there should be a separate field in the connect to server dialog.

For "Ftp (with login)" also, if I give user name like "happy;user" (created it on a Solaris 9 system), the user name is passed to ftp method after escaping, is "happy%3Buser". The ftp method directly uses it and fails.

Do you think ftp method (or smb in other case) should unescape this string before using it as username ? If so, ftp, smb etc. methods should be changed to fix this issue.

Thanks,
Dinoop
-- 
nautilus-list mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/nautilus-list

Reply via email to