Dave -

It's a bit far-fetched. The aluminium in aluminium pans is released by 
cooking highly acidic food in them - the example always quoted is 
boiling rhubarb. I don't think boiling or frying potatoes or a 
potato-and-flour dough would do the trick. That's leaving on one side 
the question of health-and-safety inspections. And the idea of a mob of 
London bankers pursuing a drunken Irishman through the city streets in 
order to beat him to death is also a bit hard to swallow.

The characters are rather undifferentiated from each other, Richard 
disappears out of the story about halfway through, and there's no 
insight into the mindset of the bankers. As far as the story's concerned 
they're just the bad guys - but of course bankers don't see themselves 
in this way. To make a story like this really interesting you have to be 
able to get inside the heads of the baddies as well as the goodies.

Having said this, the story has got certain good things going for it. 
It's extremely readable. It moves fast from one development to the next. 
The slightly-unhinged Danny is an interesting character, with both good 
and bad aspects to him, which helps to give the narrative a feeling of 
moral complexity (good people can do bad things when they're under 
pressure), and this stops it from being too simplistic. You do convey a 
real sense of how economic conditions can drastically change people's 
lives. You've also got some quite nice thematic links going on - they 
way Joey's bad dream comes true at the end of the story, and the idea 
that "repetition is the key", which crops up a number of times.

- Edward
_______________________________________________
NetBehaviour mailing list
[email protected]
http://www.netbehaviour.org/mailman/listinfo/netbehaviour

Reply via email to