----- Original Message -----
From: "Carroll Grigsby" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Sent: Thursday, January 02, 2003 8:31 PM
Subject: Re: [newbie] Failed install


>> I just think, as
>> I stated in my original note, that the install process is poorly
designed.
>> The failures I encountered were in non-critical packages, so it should
have
>> just said so and finished the installation.

>Guy:
>That's an interesting idea, but it's probably not practical to implement.
Your
>definition of "non-critical" is probably quite different than mine.

>My bet is that the new drive solves your problems.

Well, they could use a hammer approach and then refine it over time.  For
example, if Disk 1 was okay but errors occurred on Disk 2 or 3, then the
installation can start up, so finish the install. If errors occurred on Disk
1, then likely the installation is fubar and won't be able to start up in
any clean configuration, so just abort the install.  Of course, the
installer can always prompt (in the first case) "I encountered some errors
but the installation will boot up - would you like to abort or finish?"

What could be more irksome than the current approach of taking two hours to
finish, not saying anything until the end, then dumping the user back at the
start of the installation again?  At the very least, abort the whole process
when you encounter the first read error, because you know at that point you
are not going to let the installation finish anyway.  (And of course, I
don't mean you Carroll, I mean you the Mandrake installation process.)

Yes, I'm sure the new CD-RW will take care of all this.  Thanks to all for
taking the time to reply.





Want to buy your Pack or Services from MandrakeSoft? 
Go to http://www.mandrakestore.com

Reply via email to