http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/john-laughland-international-justice-is-power-without-responsibility-879434.html
OPINION
John Laughland: International justice is power without responsibility
Tuesday, 29 July 2008
Many people welcome the recent growth in the power of international
criminal tribunals. However, their track record should give cause for
extreme concern about the way that this new supranational power will
be wielded.
In democratic nation-states, the criminal justice system is embedded
within the other structures of statehood, especially the legislature.
Rules of procedure in British courts are rightly a matter for solemn
debate in Parliament. Not so the existing international tribunals for
Yugoslavia and Rwanda, which are subject to control by no parliament
or electorate.
Anonymous witnesses, which the House of Lords has just ruled illegal
for murder cases in Britain, are the norm at the Yugoslav tribunal,
where no fewer than 40 per cent of prosecution witnesses give their
evidence with their identity hidden. Such anonymous denunciation
reminds one of the worst excesses of totalitarianism; it fatally
undermines the right of defendants to cross-examine their accusers.
A culture of secrecy pervades these tribunals so that it is quite
common for hearings to be conducted wholly or partly in secret, the
transcripts hidden from the public for an indefinite period of time.
Hearsay evidence is admitted, so that a defendant can be convicted on
the basis of second or third-hand allegations which cannot be tested
in court.
The trials are inexcusably long. The alleged ringleader of the Rwanda
genocide, Theoneste Bagosora, was arrested in 1996 and the prosecution
did not conclude its case until 2007, more than 11 years later. The
trial continues even to this day. Such periods of detention, which are
common, are simply incompatible with the presumption of innocence.
International tribunals use a theory of liability which is vague and
dangerous. Defendants can be and have been convicted for war crimes
they did not commit, did not order, did not know about at the time,
and did not even intend. So-called "joint criminal enterprise" is a
sort of conspiracy theory gone mad.
Power wielded without responsibility is incompatible with democracy
and the basic principles of justice, especially equity. The Yugoslav
tribunal never indicted its paymaster, Nato; the Rwanda tribunal
prosecutes only Hutus and no members of the present government; and
the overwhelmingly white lawyers at the new International Criminal
Court have so far indicted only black Africans.
International tribunals are but the judicial wing of the new
neo-colonialist Western policy of military interventionism in the
internal affairs of other states: their power is dangerous and should
be curtailed.
Taken from a debate at the ICA last week. John Laughland's A History
of Political Trials from Charles I to Saddam Hussein is published by
Peter Lang, Oxford
__._,_.___
Serbian News Network - SNN
[email protected]
http://www.antic.org/
