This is very hard, and it's certainly impossible to satisfy everyone, but still, if we try hard to be objective...

On 05/31/2014 09:10 AM, Wout Mertens wrote:
So concretely:

  * "Help" should be "Documentation" or "Docs", I tripped over the same
    thing

Yes, the word "Help" is IMO rarely used in this sense. To me it associates to "Contribute / Help us" easily as well.

  * I miss the very visible introduction to each of the components
        [...]
  * I see no mention of Nixpkgs at all
        [...]
  * For project discovery, a 2-minute video is excellent.  [...]
      o I suppose I could make one but I feel unqualified :)

I might be in minority, but the current layout does seem weird:
- The first half of what you see is focused on newcomers (those who know nothing about the project).
 - The second half contains various types of news.
So we have two halves with nontrivial content that are useful to *different* sets of people. Newcomers will hardly get good idea from recent news (as it contains mostly differential information), and the introductory half will mostly be useless to anyone but newcomers :-)

Personally, I would probably convert the homepage to a simply structured collection of most useful links, naturally starting with a big fat one like "Introduction to NixOS.org", so we would "separate" this specific group and could provide them *more* information (the half-page is only an advertisement, and can't give a basic idea about the project). Direct link to each of those "projects" would be nice, as IMO they're used a lot.


News: currently it's more than one screenful of information (for me), so I would again separate it into nixos.org/news page. BTW, RSS/Atom are very useful for such things, and I see none on the homepage or planet. Some build status summary might also be on that page, like the timestamps+revisions of the latest channel bumps.


Videos: I really prefer well-structured linked text (with images) to videos. IMO a text of comparable value is much easier to produce. I understand that videos are better at keeping attention of some people... BTW we *do* have recordings of several introductory Nix(OS) talks, notably the FOSDEM one.
https://nixos.org/wiki/Nix(OS)_in_the_media_and_presentations


DisNix: I *heard* it's largely orthogonal to NixOps and that it makes sense to use them together.


Vlada


Attachment: smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME Cryptographic Signature

_______________________________________________
nix-dev mailing list
nix-dev@lists.science.uu.nl
http://lists.science.uu.nl/mailman/listinfo/nix-dev

Reply via email to