moonming commented on PR #2059: URL: https://github.com/apache/apisix-website/pull/2059#issuecomment-4789307900
## Independent audit (resolved) An independent adversarial review (no shared context, isolated worktree) checked factual accuracy, fairness/vendor-neutrality, schema/front-matter, SEO consistency, and house style. **No HIGH findings and no blocking factual errors** — every technical claim was verified against primary sources (APISIX, AWS, Traefik docs), all 24 FAQ answers match their body verbatim, and there was no em-dash regression. Findings and resolution: | Sev | Finding | Resolution | |-----|---------|------------| | **MEDIUM** | `llms.txt` trailing-slash inconsistency (new entries had slashes, existing ones didn't) | **Fixed** (`c388f9b9e`) — normalized all Learning Center URLs to the canonical trailing-slash form (also restored the 5 new entries, which had been lost to a build race) | | **LOW** | 5 article meta descriptions > ~160 chars (SERP truncation) | **Fixed** — trimmed all five to ~140–150 chars | | **LOW** | `apisix-vs-apigee` title 71 chars | **Fixed** — shortened to 59 chars | | **LOW** | existing `apisix-vs-kong` says "80+ plugins" vs the new articles' "100+" | **Deferred** — the auditor scoped this as a change to the kong article's body, out of scope here; the new articles correctly say 100+ | | **LOW** | no inter-article "see also" links | **Deferred** — this is the P1 internal-linking roadmap item; the `/comparisons/` hub already cross-links all 9 | Accuracy, fairness, schema, and house-style lenses came back clean. These were text-only front-matter / `llms.txt` changes; the structured-data mechanism (Article / BreadcrumbList / FAQPage, with FAQ answer ⊆ body) was verified in the prior SSR build. -- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: [email protected]
