zhukexingkong edited a comment on issue #6429:
URL: https://github.com/apache/apisix/issues/6429#issuecomment-1057625905


   > I reproduced. You should delete the first paragraph of the client.key. 
like this:
   > 
   > ```
   > Bag Attributes
   >     friendlyName: client
   >     localKeyID: 54 69 6D 65 20 31 36 34 36 31 31 38 36 33 35 38 32 31
   > Key Attributes: <No Attributes>
   > ```
   > 
   > And then, upload the file.
   
   After I modifed the client.key, this is the result, the question is back to 
square one, the returned client key is inconsistent with the client.key: 
   
   [root@2d8f65f7ad67 tlsDir]# python ./patch_upstream_mtls.py 
396932008539849406 ./client.crt ./client.key
   201
   
{"node":{"key":"\/apisix\/upstreams\/396932008539849406","value":{"service_name":"resource-service","hash_on":"vars","type":"roundrobin","update_time":1646277329,"keepalive_pool":{"idle_timeout":60,"requests":1000,"size":320},"pass_host":"pass","scheme":"https","name":"TLSU","timeout":{"send":6,"read":6,"connect":6},"id":"396932008539849406","discovery_type":"nacos","tls":
   
   
{"client_key":"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
 
D\/QCVABQaFfUX0GBpatr43lIf0drisIIYfu7Oj1sFFRgUJWVqNxznQKQZY9u4M\/32q4dCEGz8bP4bbDGe8+iNOuKSPq2VcpTpxNzdZdyAHYdYCzFGoVmMBjw0q\/vcRHZStP6BeAC0Tv2ucZtHTKSf3mMpT5t9jbYPBPaUDhS+R41i4etN2VFh6ovoj+2WPrMJ0jygxREaaeudwgoGrvWeR6FxB78SXhhCBk8hN5YdRAaAZtsDKg6iL2G52TeIvuykeNMlbqd4ITUYT0T0fBNbgYeE96l7ZKyH0P4xWjxJPTug3elCVOnm7g1UM0hKygxZJpilNs3FfBGnQ0=",
   
   "client_cert":"Bag Attributes\n    friendlyName: client\n    localKeyID: 54 
69 6D 65 20 31 36 34 36 31 31 38 36 33 35 38 32 31 
\nsubject=\/C=CN\/ST=CD\/L=CD\/O=client\/OU=client\/CN=client\nissuer=\/C=CN\/ST=CD\/L=CD\/O=client\/OU=client\/CN=client\n-----BEGIN
 
CERTIFICATE-----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\neJdgz3b3cg7rNYjpsU6jDbP8RwgUnFV9VjpEqvmb+XL7c1jaBtYOw
 
IeGQedmBMx0\nnSNTv1\/XwGuHLCECAwEAAaMhMB8wHQYDVR0OBBYEFOu6GZvXCzoq06KrSD6nrh4n\nAVf5MA0GCSqGSIb3DQEBCwUAA4IBAQAOfBB3szjT6mTWjVkWVTi1Ul34lcGspIDH\ni0ZmeZJyD+zA0NOAPVUFhHjq0tw8Ns19L4OD+yRyZB+k\/8QIROoDG0RjOrFzP7oE\nMl0d3A08ot4qmnVcd7L0eab1QxGP1PPHm1a7F51gUoCPEYdNVOPmTFgfbE6i\/4Gh\n0oB8\/6ZFB9t2QAWrmfzjyM\/CEx3j53h4hcOYiqp7sw7zXPKuYJTpLXj4aZ8mVLF7\nwXuu+I3UQvAOJjssDJ05+WEFerDNlOLryV3QVrVDQW7hYfnmguVc59Fd1OKPirP3\noZ3fyrYEQQN0XOoPT1L+CYPNjY+h9lvGF4QHUr654diXtCFOh8gy\n-----END
 
CERTIFICATE-----\n"},"discovery_args":{"namespace_id":"test","group_name":"test_group"},"create_time":1646119513}},"action":"compareAndSwap"}
   
   
   [root@2d8f65f7ad67 tlsDir]# cat client.key
   -----BEGIN PRIVATE KEY-----
   MIIEvgIBADANBgkqhkiG9w0BAQEFAASCBKgwggSkAgEAAoIBAQCBBpcYtLxaxFBS
   UE4qoiTUFLo9ESdstDSQe7VUl4xurowcoLnADvQda1C+TSdZcfFM/wyMBy6IG+EH
   zaFeYvgJbbyBErOtBAfNfCigRYHbDVJVxg3Nyau2dwd9DjDnNXrOlkqwyTg0MJeo
   sg/pDY7FLlXIg7/Sv9+oKgDBTCkBFC3oFd1s29xfYSfdqekgMBu/h6rM03NGphGw
   q/TUQQMpFY+3b5cuHU2i55C5L0Ound/Hffp9pOCnS8LZE3v4DZxPfD6XcniXYM92
   93IO6zWI6bFOow2z/EcIFJxVfVY6RKr5m/ly+3NY2gbWDsCHhkHnZgTMdJ0jU79f
   18BrhywhAgMBAAECggEAW7NFXAfH/nKb64SrqV1H83svygsRDA8fdLiXbaGv61Ie
   vpH0sm1uTiJhZn8LQmTa7LAwSK0qAw5dZuBcmeqZAop9ePbDwGmm6gIeFZqQ6hCT
   veZfFS0J30rFhbm6Q/kcaQsj1nWMfnsyrnCvIiHCoJ2H1lTc1noMCUag9sCcO+kL
   SAUGu0KA2EtIJMWfDjXcHMKcoRC4nwysCAjMVZ0C0QlwL1VGPzdgGCLAt4E8xJyB
   VA+x59rTuMPAQM0xk5mUgJlA3iwNmdu3vKlBN3iV4YlJeFmxokpe8pytOACzGsfY
   akbicVY9lZaNHchLW8jkhM9ARe2gX8ndRs29alwOyQKBgQC2oHf38bAm7jaVYm4W
   HP5is/ZPC0JwXb4OVR5rfHzhuDDN32Np5XniMbdQAgy9unppY89XuOdG/MQ98Ded
   /Vj8zZjiKMrl8hs+P30hLs1wvwf5yDt0u8G6vLMLt4BZwNecZuByjVBA3pXAdMQn
   KE4GsWkbvwiv1q1QHxqsSiV4xwKBgQC03SS++TZ7C+eHFQGnZVm+e6Q2rkoc14gF
   tMMOWPqYXdeuPYrmCjQ/SeiF9Fy/f8+Ul9iX+f6OYRe19Es9OS30pyGlfYWprMtS
   7qMkXRP3lVqgdxMy2ePP1joi682i4Pq4I9Ls9aXWv2hZCwyHvWaB3DFnWP6KcBDp
   SS+jquBb1wKBgQCLVXjSWbpMqXhJlvRouKw5ABaPDgcdldfYNYbk+PCKgi3yFFpT
   w/mu4sF6MGYqJukYGUdrJS6HEXhjzS+RwWYwUmgvPHI45/NzFZtRQtUJDSZ3oxYB
   pPJUl31/Ffy9/YxCzpa1ry0ooOneEPhK68xD/P01ZxWomoBWXbTK+DMIpwKBgQCF
   iZIL/u0exJdZwUTLV6V/YsLILL9DtE8WB3TNLx03SnJoj7/yQS56XBN2dAnWyoN1
   bvfYnhg4/68GBS1YMtOfg5bwHVGHCbHFtbR2sNKBRqD3QXPHY+E0HzQlfH0D+aCk
   PK8LjgO4HvLoa6QAxPLehrljWO33QO77j7HA4fVtWQKBgASiriIlYFcJKqs2q+OH
   fKGmzxDyM4Cq5+IkmcyjwoGWgt8CZR0YaiJgPt/CMviS0KlT3Pzp/SQdsZf/MiEX
   zENi+e0YeRW8+MYfKB6Jox2616oOV/SxWCWSfNE54llnmk+MMam49PtYTV3nrRPa
   Yl+YJnXe14Lmg8Z22tojoXj1
   -----END PRIVATE KEY-----


-- 
This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service.
To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the
URL above to go to the specific comment.

To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]

For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at:
[email protected]


Reply via email to