daniellansun commented on code in PR #2773:
URL: https://github.com/apache/groovy/pull/2773#discussion_r3740607353
##########
src/test/groovy/groovy/InstanceofTest.groovy:
##########
@@ -223,4 +223,279 @@ final class InstanceofTest {
}
assert y == 'foobar'
}
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: Java-aligned flow scoping for negated instanceof (JEP 394)
+ @Test
+ void testVariableScopeNegatedElse() {
+ def f = { Object o ->
+ if (!(o instanceof String s)) {
+ return 'not'
+ } else {
+ return s.toUpperCase()
+ }
+ }
+ assert f('hi') == 'HI'
+ assert f(1) == 'not'
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: pattern variable remains in scope after abrupt then-branch
+ @Test
+ void testVariableScopeEarlyReturn() {
+ def f = { Object o ->
+ if (!(o instanceof String s)) return 'early'
+ return s.toUpperCase()
+ }
+ assert f('hi') == 'HI'
+ assert f(42) == 'early'
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: pattern variable remains after else that cannot complete
normally
+ @Test
+ void testVariableScopeAfterAbruptElse() {
+ def f = { Object o ->
+ if (o instanceof String s) {
+ // matched
+ } else {
+ return 'no'
+ }
+ return s.toUpperCase()
+ }
+ assert f('ab') == 'AB'
+ assert f(9) == 'no'
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: pattern variable must not leak after a declaration
statement
+ @Test
+ void testVariableNoLeakAfterDeclaration() {
+ def err = shouldFail MissingPropertyException, '''
+ class C {
+ Object m(Object o) {
+ boolean b = (o instanceof String s)
+ return s
+ }
+ }
+ new C().m('hi')
+ '''
+ assert err.message =~ /No such property: s/
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: pattern variable must not leak after an expression
statement
+ @Test
+ void testVariableNoLeakAfterExpressionStatement() {
+ def err = shouldFail MissingPropertyException, '''
+ class C {
+ Object m(Object o) {
+ o instanceof String s && s.length() > 0
+ return s
+ }
+ }
+ new C().m('hi')
+ '''
+ assert err.message =~ /No such property: s/
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: true branch of negated instanceof must not see the
pattern local
+ // (CompileStack polarity must match VariableScope — no silent null ALOAD)
+ @Test
+ void testVariableNegatedIfBranchNotInScope() {
+ def err = shouldFail MissingPropertyException, '''
+ class C {
+ Object m(Object o) {
+ if (!(o instanceof String s)) {
+ return s
+ }
+ return 'matched'
+ }
+ }
+ new C().m(1)
+ '''
+ assert err.message =~ /No such property: s/
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: true-path binding of left of || is not in scope on the
right (Java)
+ @Test
+ void testVariableOrRightHandSideNotInScope() {
+ def shell = GroovyShell.withConfig {
+ ast groovy.transform.TypeChecked
+ }
+ def err = shouldFail shell, '''
+ @groovy.transform.TypeChecked
+ class C {
+ static void m(Object o) {
+ if (o instanceof String s || s.length() > 0) {
+ }
+ }
+ }
+ '''
+ assert err.message =~ /The variable .s. is undeclared|Apparent
variable .s./
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: false-path binding is in scope on the right of || (Java)
+ @Test
+ void testVariableOrRightHandSideFalsePathInScope() {
+ def f = { Object o ->
+ // when o is String, left is false, right sees s
+ return (!(o instanceof String s) || s.isEmpty())
+ }
+ assert f('') == true
+ assert f('x') == false
+ assert f(1) == true // left true → short-circuit, s not needed
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: ternary false branch must not see true-path pattern
variable
+ @Test
+ void testVariableTernaryFalseBranchNotInScope() {
+ def shell = GroovyShell.withConfig {
+ ast groovy.transform.TypeChecked
+ }
+ def err = shouldFail shell, '''
+ @groovy.transform.TypeChecked
+ class C {
+ static Object m(Object o) {
+ return o instanceof String s ? 'yes' : s
+ }
+ }
+ '''
+ assert err.message =~ /The variable .s. is undeclared|Apparent
variable .s./
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: dynamic ternary false branch must not load a pattern local
+ @Test
+ void testVariableTernaryFalseBranchNotInScopeDynamic() {
+ def err = shouldFail MissingPropertyException, '''
+ class C {
+ Object m(Object o) {
+ return o instanceof String s ? 'yes' : s
+ }
+ }
+ new C().m(1)
+ '''
+ assert err.message =~ /No such property: s/
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: ternary true branch sees pattern variable
+ @Test
+ void testVariableTernaryTrueBranch() {
+ def f = { Object o -> o instanceof String s ? s.toUpperCase() : 'no' }
+ assert f('ab') == 'AB'
+ assert f(1) == 'no'
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: reassignment of pattern variable (not implicitly final,
JEP 394)
+ @Test
+ void testVariableReassignment() {
+ Object o = 'hi'
+ if (o instanceof String s) {
+ s = s + '!'
+ assert s == 'hi!'
+ } else {
+ assert false
+ }
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: pattern variable shadows a field only where in scope
+ @Test
+ void testVariableFieldShadowing() {
+ def obj = new Object() {
+ String s = 'field'
+ def test(Object o) {
+ if (o instanceof String s) {
+ return "pv=$s"
+ }
+ return "field=$s"
+ }
+ }
+ assert obj.test('x') == 'pv=x'
+ assert obj.test(1) == 'field=field'
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: && chain uses pattern variable on subsequent operands
+ @Test
+ void testVariableAndChain() {
+ Object o = 'hello'
+ assert (o instanceof String s && s.length() > 3 && s.startsWith('h'))
+ assert !(o instanceof String s && s.length() > 99)
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: while body can use true-path pattern variable
+ @Test
+ void testVariableWhileBody() {
+ Object o = 'ab'
+ def n = 0
+ while (o instanceof String s && s.length() > 0) {
+ n += 1
+ o = s.substring(1)
+ }
+ assert n == 2
+ assert o == ''
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: reuse the same pattern variable name in successive
statements
+ @Test
+ void testVariableNameReuse() {
+ Object a = 'x', b = 1
+ def r = []
+ if (a instanceof String s) r << s
+ if (b instanceof Integer s) r << s
+ assert r == ['x', 1]
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: type-checked flow scoping for early return
+ @Test
+ void testVariableScopeEarlyReturnTypeChecked() {
+ def shell = GroovyShell.withConfig {
+ ast groovy.transform.TypeChecked
+ }
+ assert shell.evaluate('''
+ @groovy.transform.TypeChecked
+ class C {
+ static String m(Object o) {
+ if (!(o instanceof String s)) return 'early'
+ return s.toUpperCase()
+ }
+ }
+ assert C.m('hi') == 'HI'
+ assert C.m(1) == 'early'
+ true
+ ''')
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: type-checked — positive instanceof still not in else
+ @Test
+ void testVariableScopePositiveNotInElseTypeChecked() {
+ def shell = GroovyShell.withConfig {
+ ast groovy.transform.TypeChecked
+ }
+ def err = shouldFail shell, '''
+ Number n = 12345
+ if (n instanceof Integer i) {
+ } else {
+ i.toString()
+ }
+ '''
+ assert err.message =~ /The variable .i. is undeclared/
+ }
+
+ // GROOVY-12242: type-checked — negated instanceof is in else
+ @Test
+ void testVariableScopeNegatedInElseTypeChecked() {
+ def shell = GroovyShell.withConfig {
+ ast groovy.transform.TypeChecked
+ }
+ assert shell.evaluate('''
+ @groovy.transform.TypeChecked
+ class C {
+ static String m(Object o) {
+ if (!(o instanceof String s)) {
+ return 'not'
+ } else {
+ return s.toUpperCase()
+ }
+ }
+ }
+ assert C.m('hi') == 'HI'
+ assert C.m(1) == 'not'
+ true
+ ''')
+ }
Review Comment:
This is the most actionable review point, and the coverage was indeed
incomplete.
One important nuance about dynamic-mode Groovy: `evaluateInstanceof` always
allocates the
CompileStack slot during condition evaluation (needed for `&&`
short-circuit). In *dynamic*
mode this means the slot can be accessed at runtime even for condition
shapes where flow
scoping says it is not "definitely bound" (e.g. `instanceof s || true` in
the if-block).
`@TypeChecked` / `@CompileStatic` enforces the stricter Java rule at compile
time. The
cases below are therefore tested in whichever mode is the appropriate signal
for that shape.
| # | Condition shape | if-block | else-block | after if-else | Test method |
|---|-----------------|----------|-----------|---------------|-------------|
| 1 | `o instanceof String s` | ✅ visible (existing) | ❌ **new** | ❌ **new**
| `testSimpleInstanceof_notInElse_notAfterIf` |
| 1b | `o instanceof String s`, else throws | — | — | ✅ visible **new** |
`testSimpleInstanceof_visibleAfterIf_whenElseAbrupt` |
| 2 | `!(o instanceof String s)` | ❌ **new** | ✅ visible (existing) | — |
`testNegatedInstanceof_truePathHides_falsePathBinds` |
| 3 | `!(o instanceof s)` + return in if | — | — | ✅ **new** (explicit cell)
| `testNegatedInstanceof_earlyReturnInTrue_visibleAfter` |
| 4 | `o instanceof String s && cond` | ✅ visible (existing) | ❌ **new** | ❌
**new** | `testAndChain_ifBlockVisible_elseNotVisible_afterNotVisible` |
| 5 | `o instanceof String s \|\| cond` | ❌ (TypeChecked) **new** | ❌ | ❌ |
`testOrChain_noVisibilityAnywhere` |
| 6 | `!(o instanceof String s) && cond` | ❌ (TypeChecked) **new** | — | — |
`testNegatedAndCond_noVisibility` |
| 7 | `!(o instanceof s) && cond`, else return | — | — | ❌ (TypeChecked)
**new** | `testNegatedAndCond_withElseReturn_noVisibilityAfter` |
| 8 | `!(o instanceof String s) \|\| cond` | — | ✅ visible **new** | — |
`testNegatedOr_elseBlockSees_afterAbruptIfBlockSees` |
| 9 | `!(o instanceof s) \|\| cond`, else return | — | — | ❌ **new** |
`testNegatedOr_elseReturn_noVisibilityAfter` |
> *Cases 5, 6, 7 use `@TypeChecked` because in dynamic Groovy the slot is
physically
> allocated by `evaluateInstanceof` regardless of flow scoping. TypeChecked
enforces the
> Java-compatible rule at compile time, which is the correct enforcement
layer.*
Additional De Morgan / compound cases added:
- `!(o instanceof String s && cond)` — conservative: no binding anywhere
(`testDeMorgan_notAndNegation_noBinding`)
- `!!(o instanceof String s)` — double negation restores positive binding
(`testDoubleNegation_positiveBinding`)
**Unit-test coverage for the analysis logic** (`InstanceofFlowBindingsTest`)
has been
extended with the same systematic matrix at the pure binding-analysis level,
testing
`whenTrue()`, `whenFalse()`, and `isEmpty()` for each condition shape.
Multi-pattern
`&&`/`||` combinations (two distinct pattern variables `s` and `i`) and
`allNames()`
deduplication are also covered.
--
This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service.
To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the
URL above to go to the specific comment.
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at:
[email protected]
