[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/OFBIZ-12755?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=17700903#comment-17700903
]
jonathan Mirelez commented on OFBIZ-12755:
------------------------------------------
Sent from my iPhone
> Ending balance of closed period not summed with transaction entries from open
> period on balance sheet
> -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: OFBIZ-12755
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/OFBIZ-12755
> Project: OFBiz
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: accounting
> Affects Versions: 22.01.01
> Reporter: Daniel Watford
> Assignee: Daniel Watford
> Priority: Major
> Fix For: 22.01.01
>
>
> When closing a Custom Time Period, a GlAccountHistory value is created for
> each of the organization's GL Accounts, containing the opening balance, total
> debits, total credits and closing balance for the account.
> If a GL Account doesn't have any transaction entries for the time period
> being closed, a GlAccountHistory value will be created with equal
> OpeningBalance and ClosingBalance attributes, and with zero PostedDebits and
> PostedCredits attributes.
> When calculating balances, BalanceSheet.groovy will use an account's most
> recent GlAccountHistory value, combining it with relevant account entries
> that have occurred after the closed time period. However, rather than using
> ClosingBalance from GlAccountHistory, the script calculates a new balance
> from PostedDebits and PostedCredits.
> PostedDebits and PostedCredits in GlAccountHistory only reflect the debits or
> credits for the closed time period, not an accumulation of debits and credits
> for consecutive time periods. Relying on the PostedDebit and PostedCredit
> attributes to calculate balances gives an incorrect result.
>
> To observe this bug using demo data, create the following Fiscal Month custom
> time periods (time values should be 00:00:00):
> * 2009-01-01 to 2009-02-01
> * 2009-02-01 to 2009-03-01
> * 2009-03-01 to 2009-04-01
> Close these time periods in chronological order.
> Visit screen
> [https://localhost:8443/webtools/control/entity/find/GlAccountAndHistory] and
> search for values with Account Code 111100. You should see a table containing
> results similar to:
>
> h3. Search Results
> |[Account
> Name|https://localhost:8443/webtools/control/entity/find/GlAccountAndHistory%3FendingBalance_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BglAccountId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BglResourceTypeId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BaccountName_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BglAccountTypeId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountClassId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BpostedCredits_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BglResourceTypeId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BcustomTimePeriodId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BaccountName_ic%3DY%26amp%3BaccountCode_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountClassId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3Bdescription_ic%3DY%26amp%3BopeningBalance_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BsortField%3DaccountName%26amp%3BpostedDebits_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BsearchOptions_collapsed%3Dtrue%26amp%3BaccountCode%3D111100%26amp%3BendingBalance_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BaccountCode_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BnoConditionFind%3DY%26amp%3BpostedCredits_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BorganizationPartyId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BglXbrlClassId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BproductId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3Bdescription_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BparentGlAccountId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BglXbrlClassId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BcustomTimePeriodId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BorganizationPartyId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BproductId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BexternalId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BopeningBalance_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3B_method%3DGET%26amp%3BparentGlAccountId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountTypeId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BpostedDebits_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BexternalId_op%3Dcontains]|[Gl
> Account
> ID|https://localhost:8443/webtools/control/entity/find/GlAccountAndHistory%3FendingBalance_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BglAccountId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BglResourceTypeId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BaccountName_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BglAccountTypeId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountClassId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BpostedCredits_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BglResourceTypeId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BcustomTimePeriodId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BaccountName_ic%3DY%26amp%3BaccountCode_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountClassId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3Bdescription_ic%3DY%26amp%3BopeningBalance_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BsortField%3DglAccountId%26amp%3BpostedDebits_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BsearchOptions_collapsed%3Dtrue%26amp%3BaccountCode%3D111100%26amp%3BendingBalance_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BaccountCode_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BnoConditionFind%3DY%26amp%3BpostedCredits_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BorganizationPartyId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BglXbrlClassId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BproductId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3Bdescription_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BparentGlAccountId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BglXbrlClassId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BcustomTimePeriodId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BorganizationPartyId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BproductId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BexternalId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BopeningBalance_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3B_method%3DGET%26amp%3BparentGlAccountId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountTypeId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BpostedDebits_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BexternalId_op%3Dcontains]|[Posted
>
> Credits|https://localhost:8443/webtools/control/entity/find/GlAccountAndHistory%3FendingBalance_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BglAccountId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BglResourceTypeId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BaccountName_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BglAccountTypeId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountClassId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BpostedCredits_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BglResourceTypeId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BcustomTimePeriodId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BaccountName_ic%3DY%26amp%3BaccountCode_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountClassId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3Bdescription_ic%3DY%26amp%3BopeningBalance_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BsortField%3DpostedCredits%26amp%3BpostedDebits_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BsearchOptions_collapsed%3Dtrue%26amp%3BaccountCode%3D111100%26amp%3BendingBalance_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BaccountCode_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BnoConditionFind%3DY%26amp%3BpostedCredits_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BorganizationPartyId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BglXbrlClassId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BproductId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3Bdescription_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BparentGlAccountId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BglXbrlClassId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BcustomTimePeriodId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BorganizationPartyId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BproductId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BexternalId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BopeningBalance_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3B_method%3DGET%26amp%3BparentGlAccountId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountTypeId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BpostedDebits_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BexternalId_op%3Dcontains]|[Posted
>
> Debits|https://localhost:8443/webtools/control/entity/find/GlAccountAndHistory%3FendingBalance_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BglAccountId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BglResourceTypeId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BaccountName_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BglAccountTypeId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountClassId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BpostedCredits_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BglResourceTypeId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BcustomTimePeriodId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BaccountName_ic%3DY%26amp%3BaccountCode_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountClassId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3Bdescription_ic%3DY%26amp%3BopeningBalance_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BsortField%3DpostedDebits%26amp%3BpostedDebits_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BsearchOptions_collapsed%3Dtrue%26amp%3BaccountCode%3D111100%26amp%3BendingBalance_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BaccountCode_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BnoConditionFind%3DY%26amp%3BpostedCredits_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BorganizationPartyId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BglXbrlClassId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BproductId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3Bdescription_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BparentGlAccountId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BglXbrlClassId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BcustomTimePeriodId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BorganizationPartyId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BproductId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BexternalId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BopeningBalance_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3B_method%3DGET%26amp%3BparentGlAccountId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountTypeId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BpostedDebits_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BexternalId_op%3Dcontains]|[Ending
>
> Balance|https://localhost:8443/webtools/control/entity/find/GlAccountAndHistory%3FendingBalance_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BglAccountId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BglResourceTypeId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BaccountName_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BglAccountTypeId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountClassId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BpostedCredits_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BglResourceTypeId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BcustomTimePeriodId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BaccountName_ic%3DY%26amp%3BaccountCode_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountClassId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3Bdescription_ic%3DY%26amp%3BopeningBalance_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BsortField%3DendingBalance%26amp%3BpostedDebits_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BsearchOptions_collapsed%3Dtrue%26amp%3BaccountCode%3D111100%26amp%3BendingBalance_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BaccountCode_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BnoConditionFind%3DY%26amp%3BpostedCredits_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BorganizationPartyId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BglXbrlClassId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BproductId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3Bdescription_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BparentGlAccountId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BglXbrlClassId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BcustomTimePeriodId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BorganizationPartyId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BproductId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BexternalId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BopeningBalance_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3B_method%3DGET%26amp%3BparentGlAccountId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountTypeId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BpostedDebits_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BexternalId_op%3Dcontains]|[Custom
> Time Period
> ID|https://localhost:8443/webtools/control/entity/find/GlAccountAndHistory%3FendingBalance_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BglAccountId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BglResourceTypeId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BaccountName_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BglAccountTypeId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountClassId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BpostedCredits_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BglResourceTypeId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BcustomTimePeriodId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BaccountName_ic%3DY%26amp%3BaccountCode_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountClassId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3Bdescription_ic%3DY%26amp%3BopeningBalance_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BsortField%3DcustomTimePeriodId%26amp%3BpostedDebits_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BsearchOptions_collapsed%3Dtrue%26amp%3BaccountCode%3D111100%26amp%3BendingBalance_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BaccountCode_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BnoConditionFind%3DY%26amp%3BpostedCredits_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BorganizationPartyId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BglXbrlClassId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BproductId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3Bdescription_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BparentGlAccountId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BglXbrlClassId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BcustomTimePeriodId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BorganizationPartyId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BproductId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BexternalId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BopeningBalance_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3B_method%3DGET%26amp%3BparentGlAccountId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountTypeId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BpostedDebits_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BexternalId_op%3Dcontains]|[Opening
>
> Balance|https://localhost:8443/webtools/control/entity/find/GlAccountAndHistory%3FendingBalance_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BglAccountId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BglResourceTypeId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BaccountName_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BglAccountTypeId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountClassId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BpostedCredits_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BglResourceTypeId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BcustomTimePeriodId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BaccountName_ic%3DY%26amp%3BaccountCode_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountClassId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3Bdescription_ic%3DY%26amp%3BopeningBalance_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BsortField%3DopeningBalance%26amp%3BpostedDebits_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BsearchOptions_collapsed%3Dtrue%26amp%3BaccountCode%3D111100%26amp%3BendingBalance_fld0_op%3DgreaterThanEqualTo%26amp%3BaccountCode_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BnoConditionFind%3DY%26amp%3BpostedCredits_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BorganizationPartyId_op%3Dlike%26amp%3BglXbrlClassId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BproductId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3Bdescription_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BparentGlAccountId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BglXbrlClassId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BcustomTimePeriodId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BorganizationPartyId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BproductId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BexternalId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BopeningBalance_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3B_method%3DGET%26amp%3BparentGlAccountId_ic%3DY%26amp%3BglAccountTypeId_op%3Dcontains%26amp%3BpostedDebits_fld1_op%3DlessThanEqualTo%26amp%3BexternalId_op%3Dcontains]|
> |GENERAL CHECKING ACCOUNT|111100|148,619.93|200,000|51,380.07|10000|0|
> |GENERAL CHECKING ACCOUNT|111100|0|0|51,380.07|10001|51,380.07|
> |GENERAL CHECKING ACCOUNT|111100|0|0|51,380.07|10010|51,380.07|
> (Note: the first 4 values created by demo data can be ignored and have been
> removed from the above table. Some columns have also been removed.)
>
> Notice that the posted credits and debits attributes for the GlAccountHistory
> values for February and March are zero.
>
> Access screen [https://localhost:8443/accounting/control/BalanceSheet] for
> the company and generate a balance sheet with Thru Date 2009-07-11 00:00:00.
>
> Observe that the balance for the GENERAL CHECKING ACOUNT is $51,380.07.
>
> Now generate a balance sheet with Thru Date 2009-07-12 00:00:00 (i.e. one day
> later).
>
> Observe that the balance for the GENERAL CHECKING ACCOUNT is now -$116.85.
>
> This value is wrong as it now only summarises the two transactions (IDs 8006
> and 8009) dated 2009-07-11 that affected the GENERAL CHECKING ACCOUNT. The
> previous balance of $51,380.07 has not been included in the sum.
>
> Fix the method used to calculate balances to ensure that the closing balance
> from GlAccountHistory values are included.
--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v8.20.10#820010)
