terrymanu commented on PR #39026: URL: https://github.com/apache/shardingsphere/pull/39026#issuecomment-4900600381
### Summary **Review Result: Mergeable** Reason: This is a code-scope-only review; CI not reviewed by request. The PR only removes the root-level `PLANS.md` file and does not change production code, tests, build configuration, or user-facing documentation. There are also no remaining in-repository references that depend on this file. ### Evidence - GitHub `/pulls/39026/files` matches the local triple-dot diff: the only changed file is `D PLANS.md`. The PR head is `5d7e0e3ea2ce744576914a5c36f4e4cea9c55bdf`, and the merge-base is `159c9e657e8d941d8b8441a9fd1848c91efea452`. - The removed `PLANS.md` content was AI-agent planning notes, including progress, decision logs, and retrospectives. It is not part of ShardingSphere runtime behavior, build logic, or user-facing behavior. - Searching the current head for `PLANS.md`, `codex-readiness`, `plan-named`, `planning reference`, `reviewed plan.json`, and `ShardingSphere Planning Notes` found no remaining references. - `AGENTS.md` already keeps the durable agent workflow rules, including the scope gate, planning rules, post-task self-check, and the maintenance rule not to add `Session Notes` to `AGENTS.md`. Therefore, removing `PLANS.md` does not remove the only in-repository agent execution guidance. ### Review Details - Review Focus: Code Correctness Review; CI not reviewed by request. - Reviewed Scope: `PLANS.md` deletion only; latest PR head `5d7e0e3ea2ce744576914a5c36f4e4cea9c55bdf`; base/merge-base `159c9e657e8d941d8b8441a9fd1848c91efea452`; GitHub file list matched the local triple-dot scope. - Not Reviewed Scope: GitHub Actions/check-runs/logs, because this is a Code Correctness Review. External or off-repository tooling that may hard-code `PLANS.md` was not reviewable from public repository evidence. - Verification: GitHub REST PR metadata/files/comments/reviews were read successfully; there were no issue comments, review comments, or reviews. `git merge-base 159c9e657e8d941d8b8441a9fd1848c91efea452 5d7e0e3ea2ce744576914a5c36f4e4cea9c55bdf` exited `0`. `git diff --name-status 159c9e657e8d941d8b8441a9fd1848c91efea452...5d7e0e3ea2ce744576914a5c36f4e4cea9c55bdf` exited `0` and returned only `D PLANS.md`. `rg` searches for residual `PLANS.md`/readiness references exited `1`, meaning no matches. Maven, Spotless, and Checkstyle were not run because this PR only removes an AI planning markdown file and touches no executable module or formatted source. - Release Note / User Docs: Not required; this removes repository-local AI planning notes and does not change user-facing ShardingSphere behavior, configuration, APIs, SQL semantics, or documented usage. -- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: [email protected]
