terrymanu commented on PR #40122: URL: https://github.com/apache/shardingsphere/pull/40122#issuecomment-6092901598
### Result **Review Result: Mergeable** The change removes routine Jev usage feedback from ordinary task reports while preserving explicit user requests and all invocation, routing, and safety rules. No issues requiring fixes were found. ### Evidence - `AGENTS.md:122` replaces only the original reporting section; all other policy text remains identical. `cases.toml:1201` updates only the existing case’s explicit-request premise, preserving every existing assertion. Cases at `:1215` and `:1231` cover omission of routine feedback when Jev is unused and used, respectively. - All 3 targeted cases passed. The full `--mode all --semantic-stability-check` and subsequent `--mode validate` without a baseline both exited with code 0. All 310 source-read checks passed. The original first sample passed 138/166 cases; the candidate passed 137/168. These individual samples contain existing failures and variation. Required confirmation found zero confirmed regressions, safety regressions, or changed-contract failures. All three reporting cases passed candidate majority confirmation. - Independent defensive-code audit: no production defensive constructs were added or strengthened. Neither file falls within the current Maven Checkstyle or Spotless scope. No files were added, and no license headers or RAT configuration were changed, so those Maven checks are not applicable. ### Coverage Standalone local candidate, reviewed against the original working-tree snapshot captured before the task’s first write. The corresponding HEAD is `9d31ee5525337fde6fdff9ef41bc08dd0d00fb84`; both files’ HEAD contents were verified as identical to that snapshot. The complete review covers only the task-owned local changes to `AGENTS.md` and `.codex/harness/agents/cases.toml`. Other working-tree changes were excluded and preserved. The user-authorized reporting change and its semantic cases constitute the complete behavioral scope. No new project functionality commitments were introduced. Both behavior groups—policy output and reporting cases—completed root-cause, blast-radius, and tests/runtime review, followed by full-scope convergence. No new findings or unresolved evidence gaps remain. Review-ledger validation exited with code 0. This conclusion covers code and policy correctness only; CI was not reviewed. -- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: [email protected]
