- we should perhaps >think of a (dissonant) e resolving down on to the d of a G >major tonic chord,
Very well put! c John Gibbons wrote: > >>the reprint edition has a typo in the >> penultimate strain, the 1st bar beginning >> >> g/f/|egB egB... >> >> instead of >> >> g/f/|egd egB ... >> >> as in Peacock itself - see FARNE or the facsimile. >> >> The typo gives an e minor flavour which doesn't belong, I feel. > > >My intuition FWIW and feeling for music tell me John is right. >So do my eyes when I see the facsimile. My intellect (or what >passes for one) tells me that the motivic skeleton, for want >of a better term, is ed-bg. The manuscript preserves motivic integrity. > >c > > > >To get on or off this list see list information at >http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html > > >
