I've got a client that wants a specific setup for their files shares and
I'm struggling with getting it setup the way the want without applying the
permissions to every stinking folder in every share.  Here's the example
folder structure.

ShareRoot
 |
 |-Folder1
 |  |
 |  |-SubFolder1

They want the users that have access to ShareRoot to have read/write access
to the SubFolder level without having the ability to modify, move or delete
the folders at the Folder level or delete any files in the ShareRoot
folder, but still able to modify the file in the ShareRoot folder and files
in the Folder level.

I've tried explaining there are seldom good technical solutions for
behavioral problems, but they really don't care.  They feel this should be
doable.

I can set the permissions folder by folder, but they want to be able to
automate the permissions because the Folders do change over time and they
don't want to pay us every time they make a change, never mind that the
person who originally made this possible (and of course don't work there
anymore) used to just manually set the permissions practically at every
file level.  (Cleaning this up has been a real nightmare.)

The current permissions set on the ShareRoot look like this:

ShareGroup - Read & execute - This folder only
ShareGroup - Modify - Subfolders and files only

The problem I'm having is even with those permissions set, a user, albeit
accidentally, could still move and/or delete Folder level folders, although
they cannot rename them.  Their access rights at the SubFolder level is
correct.

If I change the Subfolder and files permission for the group to Read, write
& Execute, I then don't have the needed Modify permissions at the SubFolder
level, and to do that I then have to add the Modify - Subfolders and files
only permission on the Folder level folders, which doesn't meet their
requirement of not needing us in the future for this stuff.

Is there any way I can make this work from the ShareRoot?

Reply via email to