>>> Sure.  Your problem is you started with the Treo.  

Yeah, you're probably right!  There really wasn't much else to choose
from back in Oct 2004.  Now since sprint keeps giving us free
replacements and upgrades, we can't get away from them!

 

>> If you would ditch the Treo and use a PPC 6800 for a month

 

I have.  For two months.  And the Q, and the Q9, Blackjack, the list
goes on.  Our Sprint Rep gives us any we feel like testing.

 

>> Sliding out the keyboard is a two second affair

 

Two seconds is too long!

 

>>being stuck with that tiny square display.

 

I don't mind it...  It's worth the trade off for me.  I can read my
email on it, and that's all I need.  I have a laptop and desktop for
large screen ;)  

 

>> I'm constantly amazed and appalled at how poor the phone management
is on the Treo compared to the HTC

 

That I agree on.  Palm and WM Treos kinda suck at that...

 

 

I appreciate your points Eric.  

 

 

From: Eric E Eskam [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Sent: Thursday, March 06, 2008 4:02 PM
To: NT System Admin Issues
Subject: RE: Treo question

 


"Sam Cayze" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote on 03/06/2008 04:01:36 PM:

> We tested a few HTC PPC 6700s at our business.  Nobody liked 
> them.  And it's only WM 5.0.    If you are going to buy 
> something now, spring for WM 6 or 6.1 

WM 6 wasn't out when I got mine.  And they didn't have any to replace
mine with because the PPC 6800's (with WM6) were late :( 
  
> We don't like moving parts and sliding keyboards.   We are 
> accustomed to the treos, and using a device with one hand...   

The Treo's screen is half size because of the keyboard.  The keyboard is
also half the size on the Treo - I could type much faster on my HTC.
Sliding out the keyboard is a two second affair - and it also rotates
the screen into a much more friendly orientation for doing things that
require the keyboard.  Then again, you have never known the joys of
having a larger screen - being stuck with that tiny square display. 

The phone app on the HTC was much more intelligently laid out - it was
far easier to make call, switch between calls - basically everything
related to the phone functionality was leaps and bounds better then the
Treo.  I mean, after all, it is supposed to be first and foremost a
phone!  I'm constantly amazed and appalled at how poor the phone
management is on the Treo compared to the HTC - or any other phone for
that matter. 

> It's just a preference. 

Sure.  Your problem is you started with the Treo.  You don't know any
better :-)   If you would ditch the Treo and use a PPC 6800 for a month,
I would be interested to see if you really want to go back to a Treo or
not. 

Oh yeah, you can do all the dialing for phone and most other stuff on
the HTC's from the touch screen - with one hand.  It's not necessary to
have the full keyboard.  I miss that also from my HTC - the touch screen
buttons were much larger and easier to hit, and you didn't have to use
near as many modifier keys as you do with the Treo's itty bitty
keyboard. 

That's the problem with short term evaluations, you don't get to get
into the nuances of the products :-) 

I can't wait to ditch this POS.  If the 3G iPhone was out, I would
seriously consider paying the early termination fee to dump it.... 

Eric Eskam
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
The contents of this message are mine personally and do not reflect any
position of the U.S. Government
"The human mind treats a new idea the same way the body treats a strange
protein; it rejects it."
-  P. B. Medawar 


~ Upgrade to Next Generation Antispam/Antivirus with Ninja!    ~
~ <http://www.sunbelt-software.com/SunbeltMessagingNinja.cfm>  ~

Reply via email to