Ok, using the tutorial at silabs (https://www.silabs.com/Support%20Documents/TechnicalDocs/AN249.pdf), collections make more sense to me now. They are quite well explained:
Application Collections group variables that carry out a common purpose. All report items must be contained inside an application collection. Logical Collections group variables of different types that form a composite data structure. Think of logical collections as a collection designator for “struct” data types, such as a struct that groups a buffer with index variables for that buffer. Physical Collections group data describing a single data point. For instance, a physical collection of data could contain readings from a temperature sensor. So, everything needs to go in an application collection, items grouped in a report go in a logical collection…but I guess I still don’t quite understand why or how you’d use a physical collection. A single data point…ok, but isn’t that true of your temperature data without it being in a “collection”? From: Nut-upsdev [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Rob Groner Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 10:48 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: [Nut-upsdev] Developing the UPS side of the UPS-NUT equation (via usbhid) The syntax is beginning (just beginning) to make sense to me now, so I’m looking now to try and implement just a few items in the report descriptor, and then I figured I can progress from there if all goes well. The power HID docs seem to encourage drawing out your system first, and then letting the report descriptor flow from there. So, my very simplified system goes like this: [Battery]===DC Flow ==>[Power Summary] All of the drawings seem to end in a power summary, and the doc seemed to stress that it was essential to power management software being able to effectively use it, so I’ll include it. I think I understand how the usages work now….they’re basically like establishing the namespace (like com.java.class, etc). I had been confused before when I would see multiple usage() statements all following each other, but seeing it in the nut output as the path makes it more clear. So, pretty much everything should be under the UPS usage. Then I would define things under the battery usage, then the flow usage, and then the power summary usage…right? Where I’m still foggy is two things….first collections. I’m pretty sure there’s supposed to be an application collection, and then I usually see a physical collection, but I’m still not completely understanding what their purpose is. The second thing I still don’t understand is the minimum/maximum descriptors. Ok, Logical min/max I get…that’s just the range of the actual value in the report…basically a way to indicate if it is unsigned or signed. If you only have an 8 bit value specified, then I’d guess you can’t have a logical max greater than 255. But physical min/max are a bit confusing. Is it just a means of scaling or offsetting the logical value? So, for instance temperature. Our UPS has a temperature monitor on it, but HID temperature values are in Kelvin. I could define an 8-bit temperature field, with a logical min/max of 0/100, and a physical min/max of 273/373. So if I pass 50 as a value, then it gets read as 323 on the PC side? And if the physical range is much greater than the logical range, then it just scales it? The other min/max I don’t quite understand is usage min/max. I’m thinking they have something to do with the usages “OutputID”, “FlowID”, etc. Thank you for the help so far. I really wish there were better learning docs out there for the un-initiated. Rob
_______________________________________________ Nut-upsdev mailing list [email protected] http://lists.alioth.debian.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/nut-upsdev
