Hello Saumya,

> This one is specific to deal with problem of "non-unique/duplicate NVE 
> identifiers" configured either due to erroneous configuration OR

To err is human - and that's one of a myriad of possible configuration mistakes 
... listing all of them seems pointless.

> OR In case of two Distinct NVO3 data-center networks connected over a DCI/WAN 
> gateway to each other as mentioned in section "9. Federated NVAs"

That's actually covered in Section 9:

"IP-G would then decapsulate received traffic
   from one NV Domain, translate it appropriately for the other domain
   and re-encapsulate the packet for delivery."

> *          Some more elaboration required in section "9.1. Inter-NVA Peering" 
> on what kind of filters/mappings for ensuring this uniqueness

As section 9.1 says:

"   To support peering between different NVAs, an inter-NVA protocol is
   needed.  The inter-NVA protocol defines what information is exchanged
   between NVAs."

If you have such a protocol design or design framework, please "send draft" to 
the WG, as how to design such a protocol is outside the current scope of the 
architecture draft (IMHO).

Thanks, --David

From: Saumya Dikshit (sadikshi) [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Sunday, February 14, 2016 2:07 PM
To: [email protected]
Cc: [email protected]
Subject: Mail regarding draft-ietf-nvo3-arch

Hello Authors,

I have a query if the following needs a specific mention as a requirement or as 
a potential problem in the nvo3 architecture document:

This one is specific to deal with problem of "non-unique/duplicate NVE 
identifiers" configured either due to erroneous configuration OR
In case of two Distinct NVO3 data-center networks connected over a DCI/WAN 
gateway to each other as mentioned in section "9. Federated NVAs"

  *   Is there a requirement where-in this problem can to be explicitly mapped 
to in any of the architecture requirements in the document.
  *   Some more elaboration required in section "9.1. Inter-NVA Peering" on 
what kind of filters/mappings for ensuring this uniqueness
  *   This one is specific as the next hop (Overlay tunnel end-point) related 
information is duplicated.
Thanks
Saumya.



_______________________________________________
nvo3 mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/nvo3

Reply via email to