Some who follow the SI NaturaList sightings, coming from Richmond County, the 
southernmost in NY state, may have noticed the 11/5 report from Goethal’s 
Bridge ponds of very late lingering Semipalmated Sandpipers (into 
double-digits) there, as reported by Dr. Richard Veit; also out in Staten 
Island, a single of that species was reported from the Miller Field puddles on 
11/4, by C. Barron.  Others of that species have been lately reported from at 
least a few sites elsewhere in the state.  Dr. Veit had previously remarked (to 
the SI NaturaList group) that the numbers & diversity of various waders (a.k.a. 
shorebirds, to most Americans) was quite surprising as we get well into later 
autumn, from prior sightings he had at Goethal’s Bridge Pond & elsewhere. This 
seems borne out as well in multiple locations around the northeast, with 
notably late dates, including scattered reports of Semipalm.Sand’s, &/or 
surprisingly high numbers of various shorebirds (a.k.a. waders, in most of the 
world) sticking around or passing thru, some of species not much expected into 
Nov. for the region or particular locations.  (Neighboring states, such as 
Pennsylvania & others, have also been reporting a variety of late-seeming 
shorebirds & lots of other ‘late’ migrants that winter in the tropics or even 
in temperate far-southern S. America. Perhaps of a piece in some way with the 
very many late-lingering other birds around the northeast, Y.-b. Cuckoos, etc., 
etc. & also various passerines included, many of which winter in tropical or 
subtropical realms. What also seems especially striking of all that is how at 
the same time, we see the arrivals of various ‘winter’ species, including some 
of the latter that seem a bit ‘early’, as well as increasingly the strong 
irruptions having begun of many species that have the latter trait in some 
years: finches, owls, & so forth. Plenty going on in migration and bird 
movement, even now.

- - 
A Franklin’s Gull present at least since Nov. 3rd at Kingston Point, Ulster 
County, NY was still being seen on Tues., 11/6; 2 checklists from Nov. 3rd: 
https://ebird.org/view/checklist/S49645499
https://ebird.org/view/checklist/S49655891

-     -     -   
Manhattan, N.Y. City -
Sunday, Monday, & Tuesday, 4 - 5 - 6 November, 2018

-   -   -   
Sunday, 4 Nov. -

Along with the happy occurence of a rare find, by Elizabeth Paredes, of a 
(first-year) HARRIS’S Sparrow at Central Park’s north end, west of the park’s 
“N. Meadow Rec. Center”, which was seen & photo’d by at least 3 dozen 
observers, likely more, all thru the afternoon, there had been a 
much-less-happy find (just outside of Central) of a first-year male VARIED 
THRUSH, which is now in the rehab. care of the Wild Bird Fund on Manhattan’s 
west side.  That western-vagrant thrush was found near Eighth Ave. & W. 57th 
St., said to be injured by striking a window there. (Thanks to W.B.F. supporter 
Jordan Spindel for the 1st news of this.)  Incidentally, a Varied Thrush was 
banded on Block Island, off Rhode Island on Oct. 31st, and it was also 
interesting that with a large no. of Hermit Thrushes was also 1 Swainson’s 
Thrush at same banding station; their checklist for that day is: 
https://ebird.org/view/checklist/S49720648   (There was also a Varied Thrush in 
the deep south at Dauphin Island - Mobile, Alabama found Nov. 2nd, also 
photo-documented. And a few in the Great Lakes region so far this autumn; as 
one looks farther west, the species is a little more regular, including now to 
s. Texas, as just reported from the National Butterfly Center.)

Among the warblers seen on Sunday, a Magnolia Warbler at the wildflower meadow 
of Central Park’s n. end is perhaps the most notable for date (there are 
photo-documented Central Park records of the species into December, however).

Other warblers also seen Sunday in the n. end of Central included Cape May, at 
the “Knoll” by the n.-e. edge of the N. Meadow ballfields (a species for which 
there are multiple late records in Central Park, even very rarely into early 
Jan.!), Nashville (at least 2 - a species which has been seen on a few CBC’s in 
Central Park & elsewhere on manhattan CBC’s), Common Yellowthroat (at least 2), 
& Palm (more than several), as well as the expected Yellow-rumped [Myrtle] 
Warblers, for at least six warbler species in the n. end alone, seen by 
multiple observers on the day. Also in just the n. end of the park, defined by 
being north of the 96th-97th St. Transverse, at least 4 Blue-headed Vireos were 
found in separate areas. (There was also a Sunday report to eBird of an 
Orange-crowned Warbler in Central Park, lacking any notes on further location 
or observation; this is a time to be on the lookout for that species, & on into 
at least next month too, in s.-e. NY.) 

A N. Saw-whet Owl was photographed, at a respectful distance, by 1 observer in 
Central very early on Sunday; sadly, several of this species have been brought 
in to rehab., found just a short way outside of Central from rather recently, 
with varying extent of injuries. (Other owl species have been turning up in 
Manhattan, both ‘resident’ and migrant but not all been found regularly; blue 
jays, crows & so forth have mobbed some, leading to some sightings by birders.)

Good reports from the Hudson river walk, including good sparrow diversity from 
south of W. 12th St., such as late-ish Lincoln’s, also [Red] Fox Sparrow, & 
more common & expected migrants, with still fair numbers of E. Phoebe.  A very, 
very late “Great Crested” Flycatcher was reported from Governors Island; while 
there are some prior later records for this species, other flycatchers in the 
genus Myiarchus (esp. Ash-throated) become as likely, or more so, by around 
this date. The same is so of a variety of neotropical-wintering 
eastern-breeding migrants which typically are south of this region by now; 
western vagrants in same genera may be the more-likely so late in the autumn, 
or in early winter. Any late-seeming, or “odd” bird seen now ought to be 
scrutinized closely, & photographed if possible, as well as notes made on-site. 
 (It may or may not have made this list that a W. Kingbird was seen & photo’d, 
at R. Moses State Park, Suffolk Co. on 11/4, as well as the Scissor-tailed 
Flycatcher again being found at Deep Hollow Ranch near Montauk also in Suffolk 
Co. on 11/4.)

Interestingly as a sort of follow-up to a sighting of E. Wood-Pewee at 
Governors Island (which is just south of Manhattan island & near the w. shore 
of Kings Co., a.k.a. Brooklyn) from Oct. 31st, a well-photographed E. 
Wood-Pewee was found at Greenwood Cemetary on 11/4, with calls also being 
reported from the late migrant; a checklist with some good photos of that 
latter bird is here: https://ebird.org/view/checklist/S49666786  

-  - 
Monday, 5 Nov. -

More than 25 birders searched mainly in the immediate area where a Harris’s 
Sparrow was seen by many on 11/4, but there was no re-find of that rarity. 
Flocks of sparrows including White-throated (which like Harris’s Sparrow, are 
in the genus Zonotrichia), as well as Chipping & Song Sparrows & Slate-colored 
Juncos, were seen. A few of us also explored around the wider area of the 
Harris’s find, up to 1/2 mile or so beyond; in one flock of mainly 
White-throated Sparrows, close by the park’s West Drive, & nearer to W. 96 St., 
I found & photo’d. a 1st-year White-crowned Sparrow.  Also seen in the vicinity 
of the park’s tennis courts, around which are various lawn & shrubby-weedy 
patches, a number of sparrow-junco flocks, interspersed with Tufted Titmice & 
some other species, a mix that may be similar to the birds the Harris’s was 
with when seen on Sunday. It is possible the Harris’s is still in Central Park, 
& my guess would be, if it is, would be moving & feeding with its congeners, 
White-throated Sparrows which of course are widespread, rather common, all 
winter in that park. I’d also guess that for near-term looking, the areas on 
the park’s west side, within 1/2-mile or more might be among the likeliest 
search sectors for the rarity - but really, anywhere at all, including even 
green patches outside of Central, could have this bird, lingering 
(White-throated Sparrows can & do occur widely in all sorts of scattered & 
sometimes small patches of habitat in Manhattan).

A number of E. Bluebirds were again found by various observers Monday, esp. on 
the park’s western side; at least 3 but as likely 5 or more birds were seen; 
several locations included areas near & around the Great Hill, N. Meadow 
ballfield area, tennis courts, and a bit farther afield, & through the day even 
with some showers or, perhaps thanks to showers (on very clear days, diurnal 
migrants such as bluebirds can be, may move on, not lingering long, while wet 
or windy weather may cause that type of migrant to slow down or linger for a 
bit - which is one reason why rainy-day birding can be esp. interesting at 
times, the more so in months when there is some migration, which is actually 
most months in the year, in the SE Ny region…!)  A Cape May Warbler (apparent 
adult female) was again seen near the N. Meadow “Knoll”; this is likely the 
same individual present around there for a week or more.

A Yellow-breasted Chat was re-found at Madison Square Park, by that (presumably 
same) bird’s prior finder.  

-
Tuesday, 6 Nov. -

At the least the intrepid bird-walk group of the AMNH (American Museum of 
Natural History) had their usual a.m. walk in Central Park, and I know that 
some other birders were also afoot, as I saw them, including a very few who 
also came back to the area of Sunday’s Harris’s Sparrow sighting, as I did 
twice, again on Tues. - no luck on the rare sparrow, but there are still many 
White-throated Sparrows in the general area & that vicinity, as well as some 
other species (E. Towhee, Winter Wren, some kinglets of both species, mainly 
Ruby-crowned, & a lot of Tufted Titmice & Slate-colored Juncos, as well as 
Hermit Thrush & other more common ‘winter’ birds).  The numbers of 
Slate-colored Junco through much more of Central Park likely rose to the 
4-digits level, with flocks of several hundred each in 2 large areas: the 
entire Great Hill, & the N. Meadow ballfields area. (More than 150 juncos were 
in the eastern fields at one point, during a light morning spritz of rain). 
Another species that, also not that unusually at all for the date, were very 
common on Tues. were American Robin, which definitely were well into 
quadruple-digits, all through the park. A few flocks of Common Grackles added 
up to more than 800, which is not at all high for that park, this time of year. 
A few Rusty Blackbirds, and rather slim numbers of Red-winged Blackbird also 
were noted in the 6+ hours walk I took, from 110 St. to near Sheep Meadow & 
back north again. A modest number of Palm Warblers were still about (10+) and 
also Yellow-rumped [Myrtle] Warbler, with the only additional warbler sp. I 
came up with a single female Common Yellowthroat in the area on the w. side of 
the Met. Museum of Art, nearer to E. 84 St. side, the “NE” corner area of the 
museum.  I found the Great Lawn and Sheep Meadow far less ‘birdy’ on the actual 
lawns than in the more northerly sections of the park, at least for the first 
part of the day.  More generally, typical later-fall species such as Y.-s. 
Flicker, E. Phoebe, Brown Creeper, & a few others were all seen in lesser 
numbers than a week prior, which is to be expected.  Raptor & falcon sightings 
were slim in the drizzles, mist & showers, with a couple of soggy Red-tailed 
Hawks & a couple of feisty Am. Kestrels seen.

Sparrow sightings continued to include a few White-crowned in several locations 
and also a few [Red] Fox, plus Field, Swamp, Chipping, Song & the 
aforementioned members of their tribe.  Not much change was seen in duckage, 
that is of wild/unreleased or non-escaped birds in Central; I did check 
waterbodies in hopes of potential drop-ins of any unexpected water-birds, but 
nonesuch were found. It’ll be worth further watching for; also it may start to 
get worthwhile to check the gulls that gather in Central, & anywhere else, with 
rarer ones a possibility, as autumn goes along into winter.

Chimney Swifts had continued thru the period of the above reports at least to 
Monday 11/5, with many observers, generally seeing from just one to several in 
these recent days.  Reports of this species were being noted from a vast number 
of locations in the region, far later than typical for so many observers or 
locations.  In a more ‘typical' fall, one might now question if these are 
“Chimney” and not any other, vagrant species of Swift, but all reports indicate 
Chimney for now, part of a very broad trend of many neotropical-wintering 
migrants having lingered or straggled to fairly late dates in our region. 

In various areas in Central Park, numbers of Purple Finch have been found, some 
on crabapples & other trees & shrubs with lingering fruits; also seeming to 
have increased nicely have been Cedar Waxwings.  Further incursions of American 
Goldfinch have been noted, and in a few areas, at least a few Pine Siskins also 
noted, some with goldfinches, & some not.  Learning-knowing  the calls will be 
helpful at times in locating any uncommon finches if-when present, or if flying 
by.

Waterbirds in Central Park have included at least 3 American Coots, & ongoing 
Wood Ducks & Ruddy Ducks in modest numbers, as well as Buffleheads, & Hooded 
Mergansers; the N. Shoveler flocks have slightly increased, spread thru at 
least 4 of the water-bodies in Central, over recent days, along with usual 
modest no’s. of American Black Duck & Gadwall.

All of the parks & greenspaces of N.Y. County will continue to see some 
migration; November often brings unexpected birds, as we have already seen to 
start the month off, and ongoing checking of any favorite ‘patches' as well as 
those less or little known may bring a new and unexpected avian visitor to 
light.

-  -  -  -
“Something we think is impossible now is not impossible in another decade.” - 
Constance Baker Motley (1921 - 2005; American jurist & lawmaker; first woman to 
be elected Manhattan borough president, first African-American woman to argue a 
case at the Supreme Court; first African-American woman in the federal 
judiciary; the writer of the original complaint for the 'Brown v. Board of Ed.' 
case in the U.S. Supreme Court, and a victor in every case she argued before 
the highest U.S. court.)

good birding,

Tom Fiore
manhattan















--

NYSbirds-L List Info:
http://www.NortheastBirding.com/NYSbirdsWELCOME.htm
http://www.NortheastBirding.com/NYSbirdsRULES.htm
http://www.NortheastBirding.com/NYSbirdsSubscribeConfigurationLeave.htm

ARCHIVES:
1) http://www.mail-archive.com/nysbirds-l@cornell.edu/maillist.html
2) http://www.surfbirds.com/birdingmail/Group/NYSBirds-L
3) http://birding.aba.org/maillist/NY01

Please submit your observations to eBird:
http://ebird.org/content/ebird/

--

Reply via email to