Thanks Tom; although not seen by me; the Westchester Ash Throated Fly was found 
in Rockwood Hall State Park (just west of Rockefeller Park, its much more 
well-known cousin) -- both being Rockefeller owned properties at one time.  
Parking for Rockwood Hall is just north of Phelps Hospital; it has a small 
parking area just west of Rte. 9 (Broadway) or can park in Phelps Northern most 
lot. 

L. Trachtenberg
Ossining


-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] 
<[email protected]> On Behalf Of Tom Fiore
Sent: Monday, December 20, 2021 8:17 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: [nysbirds-l] a few CBC birds from N.Y. County (NYC) on Sun., 12/19 -

-CAUTION: EXTERNAL EMAIL



With NO further sightings or reports for N. Lapwing (anywhere in N. America, it 
seems) for Sunday, 12/19, it will be interesting to hear whether any additional 
reports come in, and from where. It is entirely *possible* that that Lapwing is 
still somewhere on Long Island, NY and could yet be re-discovered, possibly 
even in the general vicinity where seen for one day (on 12/18 only, so far).    
  (Of some ‘reports' of a certain "Sea-Eagle" from anywhere in the United 
States lower-48, it would be good to see any possible documentation, and 
reporting that includes some further notes, or other material. Perhaps some 
additional info. may be forthcoming, from Massachusetts, and-or elsewhere, if 
there is any additional info., that will be or can be shared regarding such - 
and any such notes or links to documentation would be reasonable to note to 
this list-serve, sea-eagle being an extraordinary bird to have noted.)

- - -
A Franklin’s Gull has been reported and confirmed at the Newburgh Sewage 
Treatment Plant by the Hudson River in Orange County, NY, a nice find for that 
county and for the region - sightings were made by multiple observers on 
Sunday, 12/19 there.  And also interesting, for the late-date, is a report of 
Yellow Warbler from that same area also on Dec. 19th.

The Ash-throated Flycatcher was among many great birds to be seen for the 
Brooklyn (Kings County, NY - in N.Y. City) C.B.C., on Saturday, Dec. 18th - at 
Owls Head Park , which is not far from the Brooklyn side of the Verrazano 
Narrows.  (And if one was not-enough, there’s also a sighting of that species 
from the Rockefeller Preserve in western Westchester County, NY on the same 
date, Dec. 18th. Both sightings, in the 2 counties, are photo-documented - and 
a tip of the hat to S.C. as well, for helping to confirm the photos from 
Westchester Co.’s sighting of this vagrant species from the west, a rare-but 
semi-regular ‘stray' in the northeast in our modern era. )

 ___  ___
New York County (in N.Y. City) - Sunday, Dec. 19th:

With many many observers participating in the annual Christmas Bird Count that 
takes in New York County (which includes Manhattan, Randall’s Island, Governors 
Island and also Roosevelt Island as well as a few much smaller isles and many 
of waters surrounding; and all within N.Y. City), I put in some efforts as 
well, and was able to locate a Black-and-white Warbler, which had been found & 
well-documented the previous day (on 12/18, first - by Dmitriy Aronov), in the 
area of the ‘freshwater marsh’ on Randall’s Island, at around 10:20 am Sunday; 
this is undoubtedly the same individual that D. Aronov had found; it was 
calling a bit and was seen (by me) with some difficulty Sunday, in & around 
dense phragmites within the interior part of the n. portion of that section, 
approx. opposite (roughly east of) the southeast corner of the large & 
prominent Icahn Stadium at Randall’s…  the Black-and-white Warbler (Sunday) was 
in-company with other birds seen such as Golden-crowned Kinglet, Downy 
Woodpecker, a N. Cardinal pair, several Blue Jays, & multiple Sparrows, mostly 
White-throated but also including [Red] Fox, Swamp, and Song Sparrow, and very 
possibly some other birds, in that "thicket-y" area.  I obtained some 
unobstructed views eventually and a few poor, but entirely-diagnostic-for-ID 
photos of the warbler.

[N.B., there’s a report of another Black-and-white Warbler within N.Y. City as 
well for Dec. 19th, that in the Flushing Meadows / Corona Park area of Queens 
County, as reported by at least 3 observers covering that area in that county, 
which is a part of NYC.]

With others having seen and photo-documunted them as well, I was able to see 
the Western Tanager at Clinton Community Garden on West 48th Street (east of 
Tenth Ave.) later in the day, & obtained photos (as had at least Linda LaBella, 
earlier on Sunday) of that tanager in trees directly in front of (over) the 
garden-gate - which was in use by some local neighborhood key-holders. I then 
observed the W. Tanager there fly in to the garden, near the rear away from the 
gate, and did not try to observe for much longer.   The other Western Tanager 
at Carl Schurz Park on Manhattan’s far-east side (east of East End Ave.) was 
observed multiple times, and photo’d. there on Sunday, with the first 
appearances very early when light-levels were still quite low, and then seen 
there multiple times at intervals, by a number of watchers, with most 
appearances by the tanager there in the vicinity of or at the feeder array, 
which is just inside of that park from East End Ave. & south of the main gate - 
or, just to the west of the northwest corner (& a gate) to the Catbird 
playground of Carl Schurz Park.  Patience can of course be helpful in seeing 
eiher of these 2 Western Tanagers in two neighborhoods of Manhattan lately. In 
either location, please remember that these are residential areas, and give 
some respect to local residents and park or garden users.  The Clinton 
Community Garden is open to key-holders only but one can observe a fair amount 
from the sidewalk, & the W. Tanager there does utilize the street trees a lot, 
as well as sometimes visiting Hell’s Kitchen Park & adajacent areas, just along 
W. 48th St., at Tenth Ave. itself. The area can be busy of course, esp. on 
week-days. Carl Schurz Park is very popular and one may expect a lot of 
dog-walkers, other walkers, family and children at the playground, etc., and 
park workers and staff. There is also a permanent and substantial NYPD (police) 
presence at the northwest edge of the public park, as Gracie Mansion, the NYC 
mayor’s family residence, is at that corner, along East End Ave. - there is no 
entry at all to the mayoral residence or its gated and fenced grounds. (The 
feeder array which the 'Carl Schurz tanager’ visits is at least 3 city-blocks 
to the south of the mayoral residence.)

Many many more excellent sightings were made for the C.B.C. on Sunday, and 
teams in all parts of the county took part in that event, of course all being 
in support of the non-profit bird count.

Among many many sightings in Central Park, in Manhattan, an Orange-crowned 
Warbler was again re-found still using the west edges of the C.P. reservoir & 
vicinity, where seen on Sunday. Another Orange-crowned Warbler was also found 
by CBC-ers on Governors Island (near Ligget Terrace) for Sunday’s count.  
Greater Scaup were among the ducks seen at Governors Island as well during the 
C.B.C., along with the Gr. Scaup which many counters were aware of at Central 
Park.

A long-lingering Dickcissel was found again at Inwood Hill Park, and there were 
many other birds seen in that area of Manhattan for the C.B.C.   A 
long-long-lingering adult Yellow-crowned Night-Heron was another of the 
sightings by the team who covered Randall’s Island.  Other highlights from the 
Randall’s Island team were a Ruddy Turnstone, an Iceland Gull (of the expected 
‘kumleini’ form), 2 Common Goldeneye (somewhat distantly off the n.e. shore 
section, as they can be seen semi-regularly when looked-for in winter there), 8 
Great Cormorants, and of course many other birds.  Full results from all around 
the N.Y. County sections of the count will not be tallied until at least after 
the end of a week-long count-period, which for that count goes through 
Wednesday, 12/22.  Also, this count is one in which there are 2 states 
involved, as the equally-important (!) other half is located in part of New 
Jersey, including some excellent habitat sectors there just across the Hudson 
River from Manhattan and from the edges of Governors Island.  The full count is 
titled 'Lower Hudson' & is usually listed for the archives within N.J., by long 
tradition and custom.

On Roosevelt Island on Sunday, I did not find great variety of birds (just as 
had been so for some scouting in prior days there) but an American Tree 
Sparrow, [Red] Fox Sparrow, a couple of Swamp Sparrows all with a slightly 
larger group of (& also scattered individuals) Song and White-throated Sparrows 
were nice to see, those (mostly) in the “Four Freedoms Park” near the southern 
end of that island, which lies in the East River, south of Randall’s Island.  
Incidentally, I used the bridge onto Roosevelt, not the tram. Much of my 
wandering, as is my usual were with a bicycle to reach various areas, as well 
as time spent walking.

thanks to the many who were participants in the counts, and to all who help 
make the counts possible.

Good birds & good ongoing scouting & counting,

Tom Fiore
manhattan













--

NYSbirds-L List Info:
https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-3A__www.NortheastBirding.com_NYSbirdsWELCOME.htm&d=DwIFaQ&c=dpn1WjMMQGUYKOlM1k1w3OIaMfTHNTwPoUrrILOsxvs&r=NwFWAUOlLbz1fEv1wZE8gwFOElNPUvOXd2Pih8klMD8&m=igfTvAMP7ZeebQiH8tUYaxd8MA7pW-_GL3BDw3MPx90&s=g29aA3tQ3qCJHxjaw016SwrYXl_6rSjDhWjSYj2jtY0&e=
https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-3A__www.NortheastBirding.com_NYSbirdsRULES.htm&d=DwIFaQ&c=dpn1WjMMQGUYKOlM1k1w3OIaMfTHNTwPoUrrILOsxvs&r=NwFWAUOlLbz1fEv1wZE8gwFOElNPUvOXd2Pih8klMD8&m=igfTvAMP7ZeebQiH8tUYaxd8MA7pW-_GL3BDw3MPx90&s=Bd_RAlcYQm2XlC1ki21mBwCjUKFm5SEb8TKdCb9zuOs&e=
https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-3A__www.NortheastBirding.com_NYSbirdsSubscribeConfigurationLeave.htm&d=DwIFaQ&c=dpn1WjMMQGUYKOlM1k1w3OIaMfTHNTwPoUrrILOsxvs&r=NwFWAUOlLbz1fEv1wZE8gwFOElNPUvOXd2Pih8klMD8&m=igfTvAMP7ZeebQiH8tUYaxd8MA7pW-_GL3BDw3MPx90&s=ZkMbb7RMgjEZWdC4bkGR_MD2RYLVoAWC-8F4nicONuU&e=

ARCHIVES:
1) 
https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-3A__www.mail-2Darchive.com_nysbirds-2Dl-40cornell.edu_maillist.html&d=DwIFaQ&c=dpn1WjMMQGUYKOlM1k1w3OIaMfTHNTwPoUrrILOsxvs&r=NwFWAUOlLbz1fEv1wZE8gwFOElNPUvOXd2Pih8klMD8&m=igfTvAMP7ZeebQiH8tUYaxd8MA7pW-_GL3BDw3MPx90&s=LVxA969hMPqA6WC5o19TEu7crPcWl6xfH3GRR7zBszU&e=
2) 
https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-3A__www.surfbirds.com_birdingmail_Group_NYSBirds-2DL&d=DwIFaQ&c=dpn1WjMMQGUYKOlM1k1w3OIaMfTHNTwPoUrrILOsxvs&r=NwFWAUOlLbz1fEv1wZE8gwFOElNPUvOXd2Pih8klMD8&m=igfTvAMP7ZeebQiH8tUYaxd8MA7pW-_GL3BDw3MPx90&s=CnwBpoPL75AQ7DlUwVW1N0bq8PmtyJTCjTBbt90NpAE&e=
3) 
https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-3A__birding.aba.org_maillist_NY01&d=DwIFaQ&c=dpn1WjMMQGUYKOlM1k1w3OIaMfTHNTwPoUrrILOsxvs&r=NwFWAUOlLbz1fEv1wZE8gwFOElNPUvOXd2Pih8klMD8&m=igfTvAMP7ZeebQiH8tUYaxd8MA7pW-_GL3BDw3MPx90&s=tPz5Z5zsDnt__5iVfMgXku9MdIL1GmlxpE_nkZ4tTQ8&e=

Please submit your observations to eBird:
https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-3A__ebird.org_content_ebird_&d=DwIFaQ&c=dpn1WjMMQGUYKOlM1k1w3OIaMfTHNTwPoUrrILOsxvs&r=NwFWAUOlLbz1fEv1wZE8gwFOElNPUvOXd2Pih8klMD8&m=igfTvAMP7ZeebQiH8tUYaxd8MA7pW-_GL3BDw3MPx90&s=hfF4PDu5yJj9ZI6Vsv93t57O6E0nDc9zAcnEXfnWON8&e=

--


--

NYSbirds-L List Info:
http://www.NortheastBirding.com/NYSbirdsWELCOME.htm
http://www.NortheastBirding.com/NYSbirdsRULES.htm
http://www.NortheastBirding.com/NYSbirdsSubscribeConfigurationLeave.htm

ARCHIVES:
1) http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/maillist.html
2) http://www.surfbirds.com/birdingmail/Group/NYSBirds-L
3) http://birding.aba.org/maillist/NY01

Please submit your observations to eBird:
http://ebird.org/content/ebird/

--

Reply via email to