Michael,
    Good questions.  The DCAEGEN2 and Integration (heat work) teams should 
verify this - I currently use OOM/Kubernetes to deploy ONAP, I also deploy on 
Rackspace as a secondary Openstack reference.
Short answers: use 32g vm, and yes Centos is used by DCAE cloudify and other 
new components.

Long----------------------------------
    For your xxLarge flavor question - using Rackspace and AWS EC2 flavors as a 
reference - https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/instance-types/ an "xx" or 2x" instance 
for general purpose (non mem/storage/compute optimized) - usually means 32g ram
    If you also correlate the existing AAI1 VM which is 1x or xlarge at 16g - 
then 32g is the standard "xx"
    I asked about this in the DCAE meet this morning about 
(onap_openstack_float.yaml)- there is no previous use of xx in DCAEGEN1 (use 
onap_rackspace.yaml as dcae1 reference)- they will get back to use - but I 
would go with 32g - remember this is a runtime requirement (as in high 
throughput production ready) - for development with a single use case you 
should be OK with 16g - as a lot of the 32g VM will be unused.

    I would recommend
| memory1-30              | 30 GB Memory v1                   | 30720     | 0   
 | 0         |      | 4     | 1250.0      | N/A       |


 For the 2nd question on VM OS's - Traditionally we ran pure Ubuntu16/14, OOM 
recommendation is 16.04, in 1.1/R1/Amsterdam we run a mix of apt/yum OSs.  I 
understand so far that the cloudify image requires CENTOS in R1.
My understanding is that the DCAEGEN1 controller is replaced by Cloudify - 
which requires Centos.
A quick search of the code in IntelliJ shows centos 7 references in DCAE CDAP 
cluster, ccsdk, vnfsdk, vfc/nfvo , ci-management, vvp/devkitdocker images

We need to update the R1 deployment diagram at 
https://wiki.onap.org/display/DW/Overall+Deployment+Architecture#OverallDeploymentArchitecture-Version1.1.0/R1

Thank you
/michael

From: Michael Ryan
Sent: Wednesday, October 4, 2017 22:15
To: Michael O'Brien <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: ONAP 1.1 flavor_xxlarge?

Hi Again

The Gen2 DCAE controller in the heat template specifies the Ubuntu 1604 image 
for its server, however there are configuration references to the 
centos_7_image parameter. Do you know how this image is used by the DCAE 
controller?

  dcae_c_vm:
    type: OS::Nova::Server
    properties:
      image: { get_param: ubuntu_1604_image }
...

      user_data:
        str_replace:
          params:
...
            __centos_7_image__: { get_param: centos_7_image }

...

          template: |

...
            echo "__centos_7_image__" > /opt/config/centos_7_image.txt

Thanks
Michael

From: Michael Ryan
Sent: Wednesday, October 04, 2017 10:06 PM
To: Michael O'Brien <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>>
Subject: ONAP 1.1 flavor_xxlarge?

Hi Michael

In the latest ONAP 1.1 heat template there are new requirements for openo and 
2nd gen DCAE controller.

For openo, the template calls for flavor_xxlarge. Which flavor do you recommend 
I map this parameter to? Here is a list of flavors in RS:

root@server-cli:~# nova flavor-list
+-------------------------+-----------------------------------+-----------+------+-----------+------+-------+-------------+-----------+
| ID                      | Name                              | Memory_MB | 
Disk | Ephemeral | Swap | VCPUs | RXTX_Factor | Is_Public |
+-------------------------+-----------------------------------+-----------+------+-----------+------+-------+-------------+-----------+
| 2                       | 512MB Standard Instance           | 512       | 20  
 | 0         | 512  | 1     | 80.0        | N/A       |
| 3                       | 1GB Standard Instance             | 1024      | 40  
 | 0         | 1024 | 1     | 120.0       | N/A       |
| 4                       | 2GB Standard Instance             | 2048      | 80  
 | 0         | 2048 | 2     | 240.0       | N/A       |
| 5                       | 4GB Standard Instance             | 4096      | 160 
 | 0         | 2048 | 2     | 400.0       | N/A       |
| 6                       | 8GB Standard Instance             | 8192      | 320 
 | 0         | 2048 | 4     | 600.0       | N/A       |
| 7                       | 15GB Standard Instance            | 15360     | 620 
 | 0         | 2048 | 6     | 800.0       | N/A       |
| 8                       | 30GB Standard Instance            | 30720     | 
1200 | 0         | 2048 | 8     | 1200.0      | N/A       |
| compute1-15             | 15 GB Compute v1                  | 15360     | 0   
 | 0         |      | 8     | 1250.0      | N/A       |
| compute1-30             | 30 GB Compute v1                  | 30720     | 0   
 | 0         |      | 16    | 2500.0      | N/A       |
| compute1-4              | 3.75 GB Compute v1                | 3840      | 0   
 | 0         |      | 2     | 312.5       | N/A       |
| compute1-60             | 60 GB Compute v1                  | 61440     | 0   
 | 0         |      | 32    | 5000.0      | N/A       |
| compute1-8              | 7.5 GB Compute v1                 | 7680      | 0   
 | 0         |      | 4     | 625.0       | N/A       |
| general1-1              | 1 GB General Purpose v1           | 1024      | 20  
 | 0         |      | 1     | 200.0       | N/A       |
| general1-2              | 2 GB General Purpose v1           | 2048      | 40  
 | 0         |      | 2     | 400.0       | N/A       |
| general1-4              | 4 GB General Purpose v1           | 4096      | 80  
 | 0         |      | 4     | 800.0       | N/A       |
| general1-8              | 8 GB General Purpose v1           | 8192      | 160 
 | 0         |      | 8     | 1600.0      | N/A       |
| io1-120                 | 120 GB I/O v1                     | 122880    | 40  
 | 1200      |      | 32    | 10000.0     | N/A       |
| io1-15                  | 15 GB I/O v1                      | 15360     | 40  
 | 150       |      | 4     | 1250.0      | N/A       |
| io1-30                  | 30 GB I/O v1                      | 30720     | 40  
 | 300       |      | 8     | 2500.0      | N/A       |
| io1-60                  | 60 GB I/O v1                      | 61440     | 40  
 | 600       |      | 16    | 5000.0      | N/A       |
| io1-90                  | 90 GB I/O v1                      | 92160     | 40  
 | 900       |      | 24    | 7500.0      | N/A       |
| memory1-120             | 120 GB Memory v1                  | 122880    | 0   
 | 0         |      | 16    | 5000.0      | N/A       |
| memory1-15              | 15 GB Memory v1                   | 15360     | 0   
 | 0         |      | 2     | 625.0       | N/A       |
| memory1-240             | 240 GB Memory v1                  | 245760    | 0   
 | 0         |      | 32    | 10000.0     | N/A       |
| memory1-30              | 30 GB Memory v1                   | 30720     | 0   
 | 0         |      | 4     | 1250.0      | N/A       |
| memory1-60              | 60 GB Memory v1                   | 61440     | 0   
 | 0         |      | 8     | 2500.0      | N/A       |
| onmetal-general2-large  | OnMetal General Purpose v2 Large  | 131072    | 800 
 | 0         |      | 24    | 10000.0     | N/A       |
| onmetal-general2-medium | OnMetal General Purpose v2 Medium | 65536     | 800 
 | 0         |      | 24    | 10000.0     | N/A       |
| onmetal-general2-small  | OnMetal General Purpose v2 Small  | 32768     | 800 
 | 0         |      | 12    | 10000.0     | N/A       |
| onmetal-io2             | OnMetal I/O v2                    | 131072    | 240 
 | 3200      |      | 40    | 10000.0     | N/A       |
| performance1-1          | 1 GB Performance                  | 1024      | 20  
 | 0         |      | 1     | 200.0       | N/A       |
| performance1-2          | 2 GB Performance                  | 2048      | 40  
 | 20        |      | 2     | 400.0       | N/A       |
| performance1-4          | 4 GB Performance                  | 4096      | 40  
 | 40        |      | 4     | 800.0       | N/A       |
| performance1-8          | 8 GB Performance                  | 8192      | 40  
 | 80        |      | 8     | 1600.0      | N/A       |
| performance2-120        | 120 GB Performance                | 122880    | 40  
 | 1200      |      | 32    | 10000.0     | N/A       |
| performance2-15         | 15 GB Performance                 | 15360     | 40  
 | 150       |      | 4     | 1250.0      | N/A       |
| performance2-30         | 30 GB Performance                 | 30720     | 40  
 | 300       |      | 8     | 2500.0      | N/A       |
| performance2-60         | 60 GB Performance                 | 61440     | 40  
 | 600       |      | 16    | 5000.0      | N/A       |
| performance2-90         | 90 GB Performance                 | 92160     | 40  
 | 900       |      | 24    | 7500.0      | N/A       |
+-------------------------+-----------------------------------+-----------+------+-----------+------+-------+-------------+-----------+
root@server-cli:~#

Thanks
Michael
This message and the information contained herein is proprietary and 
confidential and subject to the Amdocs policy statement,

you may review at https://www.amdocs.com/about/email-disclaimer 
<https://www.amdocs.com/about/email-disclaimer>
_______________________________________________
onap-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.onap.org/mailman/listinfo/onap-discuss

Reply via email to