FYI, I had this issue fixed (and verified with HEAT based ONAP) with the patch: https://gerrit.onap.org/r/49695
Thanks. Best Regards, Bin Yang, Solution Readiness Team, Wind River Direct +86,10,84777126 Mobile +86,13811391682 Fax +86,10,64398189 Skype: yangbincs993 From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Yang, Bin Sent: Wednesday, May 30, 2018 2:49 PM To: [email protected]; Sonsino, Ofir; Yunxia Chen <[email protected]> ([email protected]) Cc: Huang, Yun Subject: [onap-discuss] [integration][vid] vFWCL preload VNF failure, robot and VID concerned Dear team, Not sure if anyone else has encountered this issue, I was trying to exercise the vFWCL demo with the latest ONAP deployment (both HEAT and OOM based), but get blocked by the issue of "preload VNF data" with robot script. As I investigate this issue, I found there seems the root cause is the mismatching between the robot script and the VID portal output, could someone from VID and Integration team shed a light on this issue? Please chime in if anyone observes the same issue recently. In case that it is a well known issue observed by others as well , I can try to fix it as well. Please refer to the log and analysis below for your reference, Thanks Preload VNF data for vFWCL demo: root@rancher:~/oom/kubernetes/robot# ./demo-k8s.sh onap preload vFWSNK-1 vFWSNK-Module-1 + echo 'Number of parameters:' Number of parameters: + echo 4 4 + '[' 4 -lt 2 ']' + NAMESPACE=onap + shift + '[' 3 -gt 0 ']' + key=preload + echo KEY: KEY: + echo preload preload + case $key in + TAG=PreloadDemo + shift + '[' 2 -ne 2 ']' + VARIABLES=' -v VNF_NAME:vFWSNK-1' + shift + VARIABLES=' -v VNF_NAME:vFWSNK-1 -v MODULE_NAME:vFWSNK-Module-1' + shift + '[' 0 -gt 0 ']' + ETEHOME=/var/opt/OpenECOMP_ETE + VARIABLEFILES='-V /share/config/vm_properties.py -V /share/config/integration_robot_properties.py -V /share/config/integration_preload_parameters.py' ++ kubectl --namespace onap get pods ++ sed 's/ .*//' ++ grep robot + POD=dev-robot-845547fc88-pnfcz + kubectl --namespace onap exec dev-robot-845547fc88-pnfcz -- /var/opt/OpenECOMP_ETE/runTags.sh -V /share/config/vm_properties.py -V /share/config/integration_robot_properties.py -V /share/config/integration_preload_parameters.py -v VNF_NAME:vFWSNK-1 -v MODULE_NAME:vFWSNK-Module-1 -d /share/logs/demo/PreloadDemo -i PreloadDemo --display 89 Starting Xvfb on display :89 with res 1280x1024x24 Executing robot tests at log level TRACE ============================================================================== OpenECOMP ETE ============================================================================== OpenECOMP ETE.Robot ============================================================================== OpenECOMP ETE.Robot.Testsuites ============================================================================== OpenECOMP ETE.Robot.Testsuites.Demo :: Executes the VNF Orchestration Test ... ============================================================================== Preload VNF | FAIL | TypeError: string indices must be integers ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OpenECOMP ETE.Robot.Testsuites.Demo :: Executes the VNF Orchestrat... | FAIL | 1 critical test, 0 passed, 1 failed 1 test total, 0 passed, 1 failed ============================================================================== OpenECOMP ETE.Robot.Testsuites | FAIL | 1 critical test, 0 passed, 1 failed 1 test total, 0 passed, 1 failed ============================================================================== OpenECOMP ETE.Robot | FAIL | 1 critical test, 0 passed, 1 failed 1 test total, 0 passed, 1 failed ============================================================================== OpenECOMP ETE | FAIL | 1 critical test, 0 passed, 1 failed 1 test total, 0 passed, 1 failed ============================================================================== Output: /share/logs/demo/PreloadDemo/output.xml Log: /share/logs/demo/PreloadDemo/log.html Report: /share/logs/demo/PreloadDemo/report.html Error log: KEYWORD ${vf_modules} = vid_interface . Get Module Names from VID ${invariantUUID} Documentation: Must use UI since rest call get redirect to portal and get DNS error Start / End / Elapsed: 20180529 12:58:37.006 / 20180529 12:58:37.464 / 00:00:00.458 00:00:00.458KEYWORD ${id} = vid_interface . Get Model UUID from VID ${invariantUUID} Documentation: Must use UI since rest call get redirect to portal and get DNS error Start / End / Elapsed: 20180529 12:58:37.006 / 20180529 12:58:37.464 / 00:00:00.458 00:00:00.416KEYWORD ExtendedSelenium2Library . Go To ${VID_ENDPOINT}${VID_ENV}/rest/models/services Documentation: Navigates the active browser instance to the provided URL. Start / End / Elapsed: 20180529 12:58:37.007 / 20180529 12:58:37.423 / 00:00:00.416 12:58:37.008 TRACE Arguments: [ 'http://vid.onap:8080/vid/rest/models/services' ] 12:58:37.008 INFO Opening url 'http://vid.onap:8080/vid/rest/models/services' 12:58:37.008 DEBUG POST http://127.0.0.1:54336/session/f0dc095f66fe0fa857b6325d10001398/url {"url": "http://vid.onap:8080/vid/rest/models/services";, "sessionId": "f0dc095f66fe0fa857b6325d10001398"} 12:58:37.423 DEBUG Finished Request 12:58:37.423 TRACE Return: None 00:00:00.037KEYWORD ${resp} = ExtendedSelenium2Library . Get Text xpath=//body/pre 00:00:00.002KEYWORD ${json} = RequestsLibrary . To Json ${resp} Documentation: Convert a string to a JSON object Start / End / Elapsed: 20180529 12:58:37.461 / 20180529 12:58:37.463 / 00:00:00.002 12:58:37.461 TRACE Arguments: [ '{"services":[{"uuid":"3dcb5407-d698-4cb5-a8af-2de4dffe3fc5","invariantUUID":"c69a0d2d-6c48-4577-9233-a812d42533ea","name":"demoVFWCL","version":"1.0","toscaModelURL":null,"category":"service","lifecycleState":null,"lastUpdaterUserId":null,"lastUpdaterFullName":null,"distributionStatus":"DISTRIBUTION_COMPLETE_OK","artifacts":null,"resources":null},{"uuid":"fd3b399b-ccdd-4449-9d49-10d5b06d1f79","invariantUUID":"a9594a77-02bb-4db3-9795-78660f5ef30c","name":"demoVCPE","version":"1.0","toscaModelURL":null,"category":"service","lifecycleState":null,"lastUpdaterUserId":null,"lastUpdaterFullName":null,"distributionStatus":"DISTRIBUTION_COMPLETE_OK","artifacts":null,"resources":null},{"uuid":"97f3ad17-2acc-483d-8177-3f975122f0e7","invariantUUID":"b1e75122-06a8-45bb-b404-cae998beb3af","name":"demoVLB","version":"1.0","toscaModelURL":null,"category":"service","lifecycleState":null,"lastUpdaterUserId":null,"lastUpdaterFullName":null,"distributionStatus":"DISTRIBUTION_COMPLETE_OK","artifacts":null,"resources":null}],"readOnly":false}' ] 12:58:37.462 INFO To JSON using : content={"services":[{"uuid":"3dcb5407-d698-4cb5-a8af-2de4dffe3fc5","invariantUUID":"c69a0d2d-6c48-4577-9233-a812d42533ea","name":"demoVFWCL","version":"1.0","toscaModelURL":null,"category":"service","lifecycleState":null,"lastUpdaterUserId":null,"lastUpdaterFullName":null,"distributionStatus":"DISTRIBUTION_COMPLETE_OK","artifacts":null,"resources":null},{"uuid":"fd3b399b-ccdd-4449-9d49-10d5b06d1f79","invariantUUID":"a9594a77-02bb-4db3-9795-78660f5ef30c","name":"demoVCPE","version":"1.0","toscaModelURL":null,"category":"service","lifecycleState":null,"lastUpdaterUserId":null,"lastUpdaterFullName":null,"distributionStatus":"DISTRIBUTION_COMPLETE_OK","artifacts":null,"resources":null},{"uuid":"97f3ad17-2acc-483d-8177-3f975122f0e7","invariantUUID":"b1e75122-06a8-45bb-b404-cae998beb3af","name":"demoVLB","version":"1.0","toscaModelURL":null,"category":"service","lifecycleState":null,"lastUpdaterUserId":null,"lastUpdaterFullName":null,"distributionStatus":"DISTRIBUTION_COMPLETE_OK","artifacts":null,"resources":null}],"readOnly":false} 12:58:37.462 INFO To JSON using : pretty_print=False 12:58:37.462 TRACE Return: {'readOnly': False, 'services': [{'artifacts': None, 'category': 'service', 'distributionStatus': 'DISTRIBUTION_COMPLETE_OK', 'invariantUUID': 'c69a0d2d-6c48-4577-9233-a812d42533ea', 'lastUpdaterFullName': None, 'lastUpdaterUserId': None, 'lifecycleState': None, 'name': 'demoVFWCL', 'resources': None, 'toscaModelURL': None, 'uuid': '3dcb5407-d698-4cb5-a8af-2de4dffe3fc5', 'version': '1.0'}, {'artifacts': None, 'category': 'service', 'distributionStatus': 'DISTRIBUTION_COMPLETE_OK', 'invariantUUID': 'a9594a77-02bb-4db3-9795-78660f5ef30c', 'lastUpdaterFullName': None, 'lastUpdaterUserId': None, 'lifecycleState': None, 'name': 'demoVCPE', 'resources': None, 'toscaModelURL': None, 'uuid': 'fd3b399b-ccdd-4449-9d49-10d5b06d1f79', 'version': '1.0'}, {'artifacts': None, 'category': 'service', 'distributionStatus': 'DISTRIBUTION_COMPLETE_OK', 'invariantUUID': 'b1e75122-06a8-45bb-b404-cae998beb3af', 'lastUpdaterFullName': None, 'lastUpdaterUserId': None, 'lifecycleState': None, 'name': 'demoVLB', 'resources': None, 'toscaModelURL': None, 'uuid': '97f3ad17-2acc-483d-8177-3f975122f0e7', 'version': '1.0'}]} 12:58:37.463 INFO ${json} = {u'services': [{u'category': u'service', u'lastUpdaterFullName': None, u'uuid': u'3dcb5407-d698-4cb5-a8af-2de4dffe3fc5', u'distributionStatus': u'DISTRIBUTION_COMPLETE_OK', u'lastUpdaterUserId': None,... 00:00:00.001FOR ${dict} IN [ @{json} ] Start / End / Elapsed: 20180529 12:58:37.463 / 20180529 12:58:37.464 / 00:00:00.001 00:00:00.001VAR ${dict} = services Start / End / Elapsed: 20180529 12:58:37.463 / 20180529 12:58:37.464 / 00:00:00.001 00:00:00.001KEYWORD ${uuid} = Collections . Get From Dictionary ${dict}, uuid Documentation: Returns a value from the given dictionary based on the given key. Start / End / Elapsed: 20180529 12:58:37.463 / 20180529 12:58:37.464 / 00:00:00.001 12:58:37.463 TRACE Arguments: [ 'services' | 'uuid' ] 12:58:37.464 FAIL TypeError: string indices must be integers 12:58:37.464 DEBUG Traceback (most recent call last): None Further debug: Robot script: testsuite/robot/resources/vid/vid_interface.robot Get Model UUID from VID [Documentation] Must use UI since rest call get redirect to portal and get DNS error ... Search all services and match on the invariantUUID [Arguments] ${invariantUUID} Go To ${VID_ENDPOINT}${VID_ENV}/rest/models/services ${resp}= Get Text xpath=//body/pre ${json}= To Json ${resp} :for ${dict} in @{json} \ ${uuid}= Get From DIctionary ${dict} uuid \ ${inv}= Get From DIctionary ${dict} invariantUUID \ Return From Keyword If "${invariantUUID}" == "${inv}" ${uuid} [Return] "" Output of VID portal: http://vid.api.simpledemo.onap.org:30200/vid/rest/models/services {"services":[{"uuid":"3dcb5407-d698-4cb5-a8af-2de4dffe3fc5","invariantUUID":"c69a0d2d-6c48-4577-9233-a812d42533ea","name":"demoVFWCL","version":"1.0","toscaModelURL":null,"category":"service","lifecycleState":null,"lastUpdaterUserId":null,"lastUpdaterFullName":null,"distributionStatus":"DISTRIBUTION_COMPLETE_OK","artifacts":null,"resources":null},{"uuid":"fd3b399b-ccdd-4449-9d49-10d5b06d1f79","invariantUUID":"a9594a77-02bb-4db3-9795-78660f5ef30c","name":"demoVCPE","version":"1.0","toscaModelURL":null,"category":"service","lifecycleState":null,"lastUpdaterUserId":null,"lastUpdaterFullName":null,"distributionStatus":"DISTRIBUTION_COMPLETE_OK","artifacts":null,"resources":null},{"uuid":"7a8fabe6-11e8-4dea-8f29-f3acad35ef0c","invariantUUID":"49dba176-181f-4274-9c56-8e0d5edb7945","name":"vFW 2018-05-29 05:07:36","version":"1.0","toscaModelURL":null,"category":"service","lifecycleState":null,"lastUpdaterUserId":null,"lastUpdaterFullName":null,"distributionStatus":"DISTRIBUTION_COMPLETE_OK","artifacts":null,"resources":null},{"uuid":"97f3ad17-2acc-483d-8177-3f975122f0e7","invariantUUID":"b1e75122-06a8-45bb-b404-cae998beb3af","name":"demoVLB","version":"1.0","toscaModelURL":null,"category":"service","lifecycleState":null,"lastUpdaterUserId":null,"lastUpdaterFullName":null,"distributionStatus":"DISTRIBUTION_COMPLETE_OK","artifacts":null,"resources":null}],"readOnly":false} Root Cause analysis: mismatch between the robot script and the VID portal output. robot script expects a single service object to be returned by the VID portal: ${VID_ENDPOINT}${VID_ENV}/rest/models/services with format of {"uuid":"3dcb5407-d698-4cb5-a8af-2de4dffe3fc5",...} However, the VID returns a list of services in format: {"services":[{"uuid":"3dcb5407-d698-4cb5-a8af-2de4dffe3fc5",...},{}]} Best Regards, Bin Yang, Solution Readiness Team, Wind River Direct +86,10,84777126 Mobile +86,13811391682 Fax +86,10,64398189 Skype: yangbincs993
_______________________________________________ onap-discuss mailing list [email protected] https://lists.onap.org/mailman/listinfo/onap-discuss
