On Mon, Jan 2, 2012 at 12:51 PM, Dave Fisher <[email protected]> wrote: > > On Jan 2, 2012, at 8:48 AM, Rob Weir wrote: > >> On Mon, Jan 2, 2012 at 11:39 AM, Dave Fisher <[email protected]> wrote: >>> >>> On Jan 2, 2012, at 8:31 AM, Rob Weir wrote: >>> >>>> On Mon, Jan 2, 2012 at 11:18 AM, drew <[email protected]> wrote: >>>>> Hi, >>>>> >>>>> I own a couple of HP computers, one of which a Mini 110 includes a HP >>>>> specific Linux distro (Mi) which came pre-installed. >>>>> >>>>> The other day the system performed an update from the Mi reposotories, >>>>> including a new version of OpenOffice.org - an update to version 2.4... >>>>> >>>>> So, back to my subject line. >>>>> >>>>> Just a general question. >>>>> >>>> >>>> Responsibility in what sense? Anyone is welcome to ask questions on >>>> the user list and support forums for questions related to OOo and >>>> related products. This is a free service, provided by the community, >>>> not a "responsibility". >>>> >>>> There is no warranty provided with OOo or AOO releases, unless that >>>> warranty comes from some company. If so, that company may have >>>> responsibilities with regards to legacy OOo releases. But that is not >>>> our concern. >>>> >>>> From a community perspective, not a contractual one, I think we "owe >>>> it to the community" to provide an upgrade path for as many legacy >>>> users as possible. This probably includes a clean upgrade path for >>>> 2.4 users as well. >>> >>> I don't see any reason that we would drop access to legacy releases on >>> openoffice.org and we have been allowed to put legacy distros into >>> archives.apache.org. >>> >>> I don't think we update www.openoffice.org to full Apache OpenOffice >>> branding until we either have a long term plan or we have an AOO 3.4 >>> release. >>> >> >> Is that then why we have nonsensical statements on the website, like: >> >> 'Apache "OpenOffice.org" is an effort undergoing incubation at The >> Apache Software Foundation (ASF)' > > This language is required Apache branding. >
I believe you are misinterpreting the Podling branding page [1] When it says 'Apache "Podling-Name" is currently undergoing Incubation at the Apache Software Foundation' is puts "Polding-Name" in double quotes merely as notation to indicate that you substitute the real podling name there. You see this used purely as a notation on the next bullet item where it says: Inclusion of the http://incubator.apache.org/"podling-name" Obviously they are not saying that we put the podling name in quotes in the URL. Also, if you look a paragraph later to the example disclaimer you see that you do not actually include the quotes in the disclaimer. So I think we're out-of-policy with the way the disclaimer currently reads. [1] http://incubator.apache.org/guides/branding.html >> >> Whether we have had a release or not, or regardless of whether you >> personally think we have a plan or not, I don't what we have now on >> the website makes any sense. If you look at every other podling at >> Apache, they are encouraged to have and maintain a consistent branding >> from day 1. It is not predicated on a release or a "long term plan". >> >> Why should we be different? > > Where I am going with the CMS is towards convergence on the layout. > > By "long term plan" I mean when the project thinks we should make branding > changes to the OpenOffice.org logo. We need to have a clear consensus on > changing the logo. We may need oversight from the IPMC and trademarks. Once > we do then changes are trivial. > > So, changing the logo on openoffice.org is something that I am not willing to > JFDI nor am I willing to CTR. In this case we need to RTC - review then > commit. > > It's my opinion that the general community will interpret this logo change > and the project message should be clear about the change if and when it > occurs. > We voted to adopt the name Apache OpenOffice. I think necessary steps to implement the agreed upon rebranding can be done on a CTR basis. But I'd agree that the exact logo we adopt should be RTC. However, there are other aspects of branding, noncontroversial and reversible, that are candidates for JFDI. -Rob > Regards, > Dave > >> >> -Rob >> >>> REgards, >>> DAve >>> >>> >>>> >>>> -Rob >>>> >>>>> Thanks >>>>> >>>>> //drew >>>>> >>> >
