2012/1/4 Jürgen Schmidt <[email protected]>: > On 1/4/12 9:49 AM, Greg Madden wrote: >> >> On 1/2/12 9:57 PM, Ariel Constenla-Haile wrote: >>> >>> On Mon, Jan 02, 2012 at 09:45:01PM +0100, Andrea Pescetti wrote: >>>> >>>> Ariel Constenla-Haile wrote: >>>>>> >>>>>> On Mon, Jan 02, 2012 at 10:32:10AM +0100, Jürgen Schmidt wrote: >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Normally the office would come via the distro and would have been >>>>>>> build for >>>>>>> the distro and the specific versions of the system libraries. This is >>>>>>> much >>>>>>> easier and i hope we can achieve this state in the future... >>>>>> >>>>>> I doubt this is going to happen. linux distros have switched to LO, >>>>>> and >>>>>> I guess Canonical, RedHat, Suse, ..., have interest in building a >>>>>> brand, >>>>>> so you cannot expect their interest in supporting packaging and >>>>>> distributing >>>>>> AOO; in conclusion, AOO relies on a "universal" Linux package. >>>> >>>> >>>>> I expect that some Linux-based distributions will continue shipping >>>>> LibreOffice by default (or what they call LibreOffice; in most cases >>>>> this was simply a name change, since they were actually distributing >>>>> ooo-build, closer to LibreOffice than to OpenOffice.org but >>>>> different from both, under the name "OpenOffice.org" and later under >>>>> the name "LibreOffice"; I think they are progressively aligning with >>>>> LibreOffice now, which is good since users were often confused by >>>>> customizations). >>>> >>>> >>>>> But there is no reason to think that Apache OpenOffice will be kept >>>>> out of the official repositories; most distributions already offer a >>>>> dozen browsers and half a dozen office programs, so it is surely >>>>> possible to get Apache OpenOffice in the most common distributions. >>> >>> >>>> packaging a browser cannot be compared to packaging AOO. What I meant is >>>> that you can not expect RedHat, Canonical, Suse, etc to pay resources to >>>> package AOO. I guess (= I never packaged OOo myself, thought I have >>>> packaged some trivial stuff for Fedora) packaging AOO will require >>>> a very experienced packager. >> >> >>>> you are right and the only chance I see is that users ask for it. To >>>> make this happen we have to deliver a good product that users want and >>>> that they would prefer over a pre-installed LibreOffice. Especially when >>>> it comes to commercial usage in companies this can be a key factor to >>> >>> convince the distros to provide AOO as well. >> >> >>>> Juergen >> >> >> New to gmail for lists, hope this is clear. >> >> I use Debian, it has switched to LO, previously it was Go-Office,( >> Novell)already forking from pure OO. >> I have strong differences with how the LO devs are 'enhancing' the >> product. They have created at least one new feature that breaks >> backwards compatibility with previous versions of OO. >> Table>border/line styles >> >> I have a 9 year archive of business reports that would need to be >> edited to be usable. >> https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=38542,& 42750. >> >> >> I have downloaded ver 3.4 from http://people.apache.org/~arielch/packages/ >> These work with my archived reports, >> >> Not sure how the code flows from one project to the other, my hope is >> that OO does not duplicate what LO is doing. >> >>Greg Madden > > i can say for sure that we don't use the work of LibreOffice. If we would > wanted to do that we simply could not because of the license. > > Well we would be of course interested in some cleanup work, bug fixes or > improvements they have done but we can't use it. So we definitely will have > to duplicate some work in the future which is the drawback of the whole > license story :-( > > Juergen
I sounded a bit negative, frustrated really. LO is doing some fine work. A key point, improvements are not improvements if they break the user experience, Greg
