On Tue, 13 Mar 2012 17:52:43 -0400 Rob Weir <[email protected]> wrote:
> On Tue, Mar 13, 2012 at 5:25 PM, Raphael Bircher > <[email protected]> wrote: > > Am 13.03.12 22:18, schrieb Rob Weir: > >> The "about" box in the dev snapshots says: > >> > >> "Apache OpenOffice acknowledges all community members, > >> especially those mentioned at > >> http://www.openoffice.org/welcome/credits.html" > >> > >> But that page has not been updated. > >> > >> Was this page just manually updated, or do we generate it > >> from some data file? > >> > >> What criteria do we use for inclusion? > > As I know, this is only a list of people who field a SCA (Sun > > Copyright Agreement) but I'm not 100% sure. I'm not there for > > exemple. > >> > > So what do we have for AOO? > > - We have a list of committers > > - We have another list of people who have signed ICLAs and > indicated they were interested in AOO. > > - We have a list of everyone who has committed to Subversion. > This is a subset of the committers. Due to our use of > Subversion, any patch by a 3rd party would need to be applied > and committed via a committer. > > - We have a list of everyone who as contributed bug reports > > - We have a list of forum volunteers > > - We have a list of everyone who as contributed to maintaining > the website, the wikis, etc., both project members and Apache > Infra (and now Source Forge as well) > > - We have a list of everyone who subscribes or posts to the > mailing lists > > So it takes a lot of people to make a project like this succeed. > Listing them all would be great. Trying to list them all, but > failing, would risk offending those that we leave out. > > So I think my emerging preference is to list everyone, or to > list no one, but make a generic statement thanking the "many > volunteers who have made this release possible" or similar. > > -Rob > > > >> Do we want to make a page for "legacy" contributors and then > >> have the main page be for "current" ones? > >> > >> I'm not proposing any particular solution. I'm just noting > >> that the current stale data probably pleases no few of us. > >> > >> -Rob > > > A list of specific contributors will almost certainly _always_ be wrong and need to much maintenance to maintain (even though wrong!), so a general statement thanking the many who have contributed to this project in any way seems most appropriate. -- Rory O'Farrell <[email protected]>
