On Thu, 2012-04-26 at 07:15 +1000, Jean Weber wrote: > On Wed, Apr 25, 2012 at 21:27, Rob Weir <[email protected]> wrote: > > On Wed, Apr 25, 2012 at 6:03 AM, Jean Weber <[email protected]> wrote: > >> Can ODFAuthors use the AOO logo on the cover of the user guides we are > >> producing to AOO? > >> > > > > The relevant ASF policy is here: > > > > http://www.apache.org/foundation/marks/faq/#booktitle > > > > Note the preferred attribution. > > > >> Related question: with the license for these books being CC-BY, not > >> Apache-2, I have never been clear just what relationships these books > >> will have to AOO. I realise that they will not be considered part of > >> the official AOO product offering, but beyond that I'm not sure... are > >> they "community produced documentation" or "third party documentation" > >> or what? I know this has been talked about, but if there's been a > >> definitive statement I've apparently missed it. > >> > > > > I don't think it is an either/or thing. ODFAuthors is both 3rd party > > as well as community-produced. It is certainly 3rd party: It is not > > under the ALv2 license; it does not have source files in SVN; it is > > not being voted on the PMC for release; it is not being distributed > > along with other officially released project modules. > > > >> Personally, I don't care what status the project decides that these > >> books can have; I just want to know what it is, so I don't > >> inadvertently do something wrong. > >> > > > > Main thing is to avoid having the user be confused about the source of > > the documentation. It is from ODFAuthors, not AOO. So when we host > > the files on the wiki, we should make sure it is clear to the user > > where to report errors,where they can go to volunteer, who they can > > thank, etc. > > > OK, it looks like as a practical matter, using the logo on the cover > is out, at least for the first iteration of the Getting Started book. > We're unlikely to have time to get a cover design approved by > trademarks before the book is published -- unless Drew or someone is > even more speedy than usual at coming up with a design. No problem; > there's always next time...
Well, how speedy is speedy - I was going to work on the couple of wiki/site pages I raised my hand on next - but I could work on a cover today instead. If it is just an official logo and a little text work - no biggie at all. > assuming we want the logo there at all. w/something other then the official logo a bit longer as it means actually designing something :) Let me know either way, //drew > IMO, it's not really necessary and could well convey to users the > incorrect idea that the book is official, regardless of what the > attribution on the copyright page says (almost no one reads copyright > pages). > > I'll amend the attribution on the draft copyright page of the book; > thanks for the pointer. I should have remembered that page. > > --Jean
