On Jun 23, 2012, at 3:58 AM, TJ Frazier wrote:

> On 6/22/2012 17:35, Dave Fisher wrote:
>> Hi Jürgen,
>> 
>> I've moved the navigation over to the righthand side. I think that looks 
>> much better.
>> 
>> Please see 
>> http://ooo-site.staging.apache.org/api/docs/common/ref/com/sun/star/auth/module-ix.html
>> 
> <snip>
> 
> Dave,
> 
> A few thoughts on the nav column:
> 
> * (Personal): "You are messing with the tools in my workshop. You need a very 
> good reason to do that ... "

Forgive me. I tool the opening to suggest a change. It is easily reversible 
although it takes a couple of hours because the API is big.

This is also staged, it is there for RTC. Revert? If so simply revert 
templates/api/ssi.mdtext and leave the rightnav work in content/css/ooo.css.

> 
> * Both Mwiki and Cwiki have their nav info on the left. For those accustomed 
> to LTR languages, there is a certain natural hierarchy of position involved.

I think that if the content is the main focus then for LTR languages having 
subsidiary navigation on the right makes more sense. What wikis do may be 
different. The main API page uses a right nav.

> 
> * Is a nav column really the best use of screen real-estate? The Apache main 
> site cleverly relegates a lot of navigation to the footer. Perhaps a 
> "Navigation" button link thereto?

Agreed. These pages already have two or three layers of horizontal buttons in a 
mess of styles.

> 
> * IIRC, the SDK provides a local copy of the API. Will that look the same as 
> the web site?

No and it would be good to consider the needs of both in the SDK generation 
which AFAIK is what Jürgen is providing with this update.

If you'd like to I can work with you slowly to correct these issues.

HTH,
Dave


> 
> /tj/
> 

Reply via email to