AFS doesn't require a 'primary server' nor does it require segregation of RW volumes and RO volumes.

It will help to know what makes a server your 'primary.'

That being said, some sites do consider a specific AFS file server to be their 'primary.' This may be for non-AFS reasons. For example, some sites have kept RW data on beefier (faster/higher availability/whatever) hardware, and want all RWs kept on that hardware. If for this or some other reason you've segregated RW volumes from RO, by all means restore to your 'primary.'

In general a volume can be restored to any server/partition with sufficient space.

There are different types of restores. Two that come to mind are 'restore to replace corrupted volume' and 'restore to retrieve file I just mangled beyond hope.'

To replace a corrupted volume I can restore over an existing volume (overwrite in place using the same volume name and location) if I so choose -- this is generally easier because I don't have to remove the corrupted volume and don't have to finagle the VLDB entry, and won't get complaints that "a volume of this name already exists," etc.

I can restore without overwriting existing volume, for example to retrieve some subset of files/directories from time X. (different name, location as convenient.)

As for being 'standard' to restore data to the primary? I don't, others may.

I never taught this as best or even recommended practice when teaching for Transarc/IBM or later when teaching my own classes, but your hardware configuration or some other factor may make it relevant to your AFS installation.

Kim Kimball


Jeff Greer wrote:
Is it standard to restore data to the primary AFS server from a read only replica server?

Thanks.

Jeff

_______________________________________________
OpenAFS-info mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openafs.org/mailman/listinfo/openafs-info


_______________________________________________
OpenAFS-info mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openafs.org/mailman/listinfo/openafs-info

Reply via email to