Hi Harald,

> Please see the pcap files in https://people.osmocom.org/laforge/pcap/
>
> specifically
> https://people.osmocom.org/laforge/pcap/osmobsc-nanobts-efr-dtx.pcap

The server returns "403 Forbidden" for the linked file and for most
other pcap files in that directory, including most interesting ones.

[sysmoBTS FACCH issue]
> I would agree this is a bug. Irrespective of whether you have a (hacky
> or not) patch, it would make sense to have this in the osmo-bts bug
> tracker.

OK, I will write up the bug issue.

> To my big surprise, my Osmocom setup worked fine with the nanoBTS 
> i have (model 165AU, DCS1800). I'd have expected more bit-rot given that
> we don't know anyone regularly using such a setup anymore.

My first attempt was almost a year ago in 2022-04, using a PCS1900
unit.  I posted my pcap file on the ML, you looked at it and told me
that there seemed to be a problem with TA control loop.  Yesterday I
tried with my GSM850 unit and the behaviour appeared to be the same.

> There was one bug in osmo-bsc I had addressed in
> https://osmocom.org/issues/5959

Does your fix make the difference between the setup working and not
working?  IOW, did it work prior to your WIP OS#5959 fix?  If the setup
worked even before that fix, then it probably won't fix whatever issue
I am having here.

M~

Reply via email to