Maybe the spec should carry an informative note to implementors to point out
that the HEAD element does not necessarily have any textual representation in
the HTML source?

Comments?

See the general archives for a thread between the 9th and 10th of this month about outsourcing headers: restricting the scan for OpenID headers to this "HEAD" area (*before* the "BODY" starts") is actually *desirable* behavior, since it would prevent Identity theft from injecting HTML in embedded comments, guestbooks, basically anything that is dynamically generated server-side rather than linked to within the page (like CSS).

The advisory for security should carry a note to implementors about this, pointing out that the attack works even in the absence of users (or servers) not actively supporting OpenID; permitting the theft of Identity victims never even realized they had would not be a good PR achievement for OpenID.

-Shade
_______________________________________________
specs mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.openid.net/mailman/listinfo/openid-specs

Reply via email to