As it turns out, it is the version of Xcode / macOS SDK that was used
the compile the JDK that matters, regardless of what we use to compile
JavaFX. That makes this is a more serious bug than initially thought.
I can reproduce it, and have sent a pull request for review:
https://github.com/openjdk/jfx/pull/981
-- Kevin
On 12/21/2022 5:42 AM, Kevin Rushforth wrote:
As Johan said, the JavaFX releases are currently built with Xcode
12.4, so JDK-8296654 isn't directly relevant, unless it doesn't fully
describe the problem. If you are seeing a crash on macOS 13 Ventura
with the downloaded JavaFX SDK (built with Xcode 12.4), that would be
a much more serious bug.
Do you have a reproducible test case using a build from openjfx.io or
jdk.java.net?
I plan to do some macOS 13 testing in the next day or two, so can take
a look if there is a reproducer.
-- Kevin
On 12/21/2022 12:26 AM, Johan Vos wrote:
There will be a new JavaFX 19 release with the security patches for
2023Q1 (scheduled Jan 17).
Typically, those maintenance releases contain a few selected
backports from the head version.
However, in this case it seems unlikely to me as JDK-8296654 is not
resolved.
Once resolved, that is something that could go in the LTS backports
for 11 and 17.
Looking into JDK-8296654, I'm not sure I understand the issue, as the
builds we do are with XCode 12.4 so that should not cause problems?
- Johan
On Wed, Dec 21, 2022 at 9:06 AM Glavo <zjx001...@gmail.com> wrote:
Will JavaFX 19 release an updated version?
We have received a lot of feedback about program crashes on the
macOS. These crashes should be caused by JDK-8296654.
Because our program needs to be compatible with Java 11~16, it
cannot be updated to JavaFX 20.
It would be great if we could fix this problem in JavaFX 19.
On Tue, Dec 20, 2022 at 4:10 AM Kevin Rushforth
<kevin.rushfo...@oracle.com> wrote:
As a reminder, Rampdown Phase 1 (RDP1) for JavaFX 20 starts
on January
12, 2023 at 16:00 UTC (08:00 Pacific time). Given the
upcoming holidays,
that's a little over 2 working weeks from now.
During rampdown of JavaFX 20, the "master" branch of the jfx
repo will
be open for JavaFX 21 fixes.
Please allow sufficient time for any feature that needs a
CSR. New
features should be far enough along in the review process
that you can
finalize the CSR no later than Thursday, January 5, or it is
likely to
miss the window for this release, in which case it can be
targeted for
JavaFX 21.
We will follow the same process as in previous releases for
getting
fixes into JavaFX 20 during rampdown. I'll send a message
with detailed
information when we fork, but candidates for fixing during
RDP1 are
P1-P3 bugs (as long as they are not risky) and test or doc
bugs of any
priority. Some small enhancements might be considered during
RDP1, but
they require explicit approval; the bar will be high for such
requests.
-- Kevin
On 11/1/2022 1:59 PM, Kevin Rushforth wrote:
> Here is the proposed schedule for JavaFX 20.
>
> RDP1: Jan 12, 2023 (aka “feature freeze”)
> RDP2: Feb 2, 2023
> Freeze: March 2, 2023
> GA: March 21, 2023
> We plan to fork a jfx20 stabilization branch at RDP1.
>
> The start of RDP1, the start of RDP2, and the code freeze
will be
> 16:00 UTC on the respective dates.
>
> Please let Johan or me know if you have any questions.
>
> -- Kevin
>
