Uwe, helllo.

On 20 Feb 2023, at 13:28, Uwe Sauter wrote:

> ldapsearch -x -H 'ldap://<HOST>/dc=example,dc=net' '(cn=foo)'
>
>  instead of
>
>  ldapsearch -x -H 'ldap:///dc=example,dc=net' '(cn=foo)'

No: the documentation for the -H option says that the SRV-lookup form, with the 
dc= components, is only tried when the host:port element of the URI is empty.

Looking at the code, the problem does appear to be that common.c:tool_args 
attempts to break the -H argument into multiple LDAP URIs by separating at 
commas, as well as spaces.  That's the right thing to do to match the first 
sentence of the ldapsearch(1) documentation of -H, but the second sentence 
there (the one starting 'As an exception...') doesn't mention a list of SRV 
names (sensibly, since an SRV record is implicitly a list anyway), so 
shouldn't, I think, attempt to split the argument.

As the code stands, you have to escape the ',' in order to trick the code into 
not splitting this argument.

I noted in the OP that there's a mild code change which would make this work as 
expected.

I'm raise this as a bugreport with suggested fix, since it doesn't sound from 
this discussion that there's something obvious I'm missing.

Best wishes,

Norman


-- 
Norman Gray  :  https://nxg.me.uk

Reply via email to