This case was not approved at today's LSARC meeting because it is clear that the one-pager needs to be updated to reflect the issues highlighted in the discussion below. Please update the one-pager so the review can continue.
I extended the timer for this case until 02/24/2010 to give time to update the one-pager for this case. Jeff, Simon: can you provide an updated one-pager? Thanks, Brian On 02/09/10 20:55, yuntong.jin wrote: > Hi Peter, > Thanks for the feedback, please check my comments inline: > > On 02/ 8/10 09:06 PM, Peter Tribble wrote: >> On Mon, Feb 8, 2010 at 2:52 AM, Qing-Ming Jeff Cai >> <qc161282 at sac.sfbay.sun.com> wrote: >> ... >>> 2. Project Summary >>> 2.1. Project Description: >>> >>> Libchamplain is a Clutter based map ClutterActor and Gtk+ widget to >>> display >>> street maps, cycle maps or other maps. >> Which version? I don't see that mentioned. > The version is 0.43, i will add it into update. >>> libchamplain loads maps from the network using libsoup. >> I notice, however, that libsoup isn't listed in the Interface table. >> Shouldn't it be? > Yes, it should be. >> The libchamplain web pages also list Cairo as a dependency. Is it? >> > Cairo is a fundamental library, is included in SUNWclutter-gtk as > dependency, so no need mention it here again. >>> Some >>> preconfigured network map sources are built into this library. >> Is there a mechanism to configure the list of sources? >> > Map sources are preconfigured in hard code, so no GUI kind of configure > mechanism here. >>> Imported Interfaces Stability Comments >>> -------------------- --------------- ----------------------- >>> SUNWgobject-introspection Volatile LSARC/2009/442/ >> ... > SUNWgobject-introspection being used in compile time to generate GIR > file (An XML format called GIR containing introspection information) , > so it should not be listed as imported interfaces here. > i will update this. >>> 4.5. Dependencies: >>> >>> SUNWgobject-introspection >> Why is gobject-introspection listed? It's not obvious to me that >> shipping files for its use is any different than shipping .pc files >> for pkgconfig, and that's not listed. >> > We do ship .pc files: > /usr/lib/pkgconfig/champlain-0.4.pc Uncommitted > /usr/lib/pkgconfig/champlain-gtk-0.4.pc Uncommitted > > > BR, > Simon > >> Thanks, >> >
