On Mar 11, 2010, at 10:45 PM, Garrett D'Amore wrote:
> On 03/11/10 10:09 PM, Lukas Rovensky wrote:
>> On 3/12/10 6:24 AM, Garrett D'Amore wrote:
>>> On 03/11/10 03:17 PM, Don Cragun wrote:
>>>> On Mar 11, 2010, at 11:42:30 -0800, Garrett D'Amore wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> SInce nobody else has said so explicitly yet, +1 on the case, and +1 on
>>>>> just needing the single case. (I.e. I'm +1'ing both the announce in S10
>>>>> and the removal in OpenSolaris.)
>>>>>
>>>>> - Garrett
>>>> Garrett,
>>>> I think you're missing the point. The case as written announces the
>>>> removal of MySQL 4.0 from S10 and removes MySQL 4.0 from S10 as a
>>>> patch. I believe everyone that has commented so far would be happy
>>>> if the case announced the future removal with a patch or micro binding,
>>>> but had a minor release binding for the actual removal of the product
>>>> rather than a patch binding.
>>>>
>>>> Removing an old, supported interface as part in a patch is NOT
>>>> appropriate!
>>>
>>> Oh, I misread that... I thought the case was only proposing to announce
>>> the removal in S10. Actually *removing* it in S10 is not really
>>> appropriate, removing it in the next release is fine.
>>>
>>> So I'm going to have to retract the +1 that relates to the removal in
>>> S10. A removal in SNV is OK. (Assuming it already hasn't happened.)
>>>
>>> - Garrett
>>>> - Don
>>>
>> Hi all,
>>
>> no, please -- the case really wants to *remove* MySQL 4 from *SNV* and only
>> *obsolete* MySQL 4 in *S10*. That's it. If later on it is possible to
>> remove MySQL from S10 then this will be certainly desired but this is not
>> goal of this case.
>
> Okay, so that's what I *thought* I was +1'ing. So you have my +1. :-)
>
> - Garrett
No. That is not what the case says. Quoting from the original
materials:
1. From your intro to the case: "Binding is patch."
2. From the interface table in the case (section 5): "All the interfaces
described below will be obsoleted in Solaris 10." (This is fine with
a patch binding.)
3. From the interface table in the case (section 5): "MySQL 4.0 binaries
from /usr/sfw/bin will be removed:", "MySQL 4.0 libraries from
/usr/sfw/lib will be removed:", "MySQL 4.0 man pages from
/usr/sfw/man/man1 will be removed:", "MySQL 4.0 include files from
/usr/sfw/mysql/include will be removed including the entire
directory.", "MySQL 4.0 tests in /usr/sfw/mysql will be removed,
including the entire directory.", and "MySQL 4.0 I18N and config
files at /usr/sfw/share/mysql/ will be removed, including the entire
directory, and the file /usr/sfw/share/info/mysql.info". (These all
need a minor release binding; not a patch binding.)
- Don
>>
>> Thanks,
>> Luksa
>
