Bonsoir,

Hodie XVII Kal. Oct. MMVII est, Bynum, Don scripsit:
>    i have been setting up a CA and have one hurdle which I cannot figure
>    out.  I have geberated a CRL (currently with no revoked certs).  It is
>    regerenced in the CRL Distribution Points extension of the end entity
>    certs.  I can open the CRL with IE by browsing to the CRL URI.  I can
>    import it into Firefox.  However, when browsing to a site (IE or FF)  with
>    a cert from the CA of the CRL, I get an error saying that the CRL is
>    invalid.
> 
>    You can see this for yourself :
>    [1]http://crl1.networksolutions.com/SiteSafeSSL.crl
>    A test site for this is at [2]https://www.netsol-test-site-4.com

Taken from the CRL:

Issuer: /CN=SiteSafe SSL/O=Network Solutions LLC/C=US
        CRL extensions:
            X509v3 Authority Key Identifier: 
                
keyid:2A:CB:BC:20:CE:C6:DF:9A:1C:AD:A5:C6:38:86:BB:5C:01:32:A6:B4
                DirName:/C=US/O=Network Solutions LLC/CN=SiteSafe
                serial:0A

The Issuer and authorityKeyIdentifier/DirName should point to the same
authority, i.e. should have the same exact name. Order is important,
and it's reversed, here.

I think that usual software don't use the DirName and/or serial part
of the authorityKeyIdentifier extension, only the keyId (and in fact,
I made some tests a few months ago, Firefox didn't follow the keyId,
when IE did). So I assume that the validating software uses the Issuer
field of the CRL to check if it has been signed by the same CA.
My guess is that the real name of your CA is the one we can see in the
extension, not the one set in the Issuer field. Could you check it?

-- 
Erwann ABALEA <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
______________________________________________________________________
OpenSSL Project                                 http://www.openssl.org
User Support Mailing List                    [email protected]
Automated List Manager                           [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to