-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA256 On 17/11/14 09:01, Denis Makogon wrote: > I'm not sure I understand you statement about them not being > "gate"-able - the functional/unit tests currently proposed for the > zmq driver run fine as part of the standard test suite execution - > maybe the confusion is over what 'functional' actually means, but > in my opinion until we have some level of testing of this driver, > we can't effectively make changes and fix bugs. > > I do agree that there's a confusion what "functional testing" > means. Another thing, what the best solution is? Unit tests are > welcome, but they are still remain to be units (they are using > mocks, etc.) I'd try to define what 'fuctional testing' means for > me. Functional testing in oslo.messaging means that we've been > using real service for messaging (in this case - deployed 0mq). So, > the simple definition, in term os OpenStack integration, we should > be able to run full Tempest test suit for OpenStack services that > are using oslo.messaging with enabled zmq driver. Am i right or > not?
0mq is just a set of messaging semantics on top of tcp/ipc sockets; so its possible to test the entire tcp/ipc messaging flow standalone i.e. without involving any openstack services. That's what the current test proposal includes - unit tests which mock out most things, and base functional tests that validate the tcp/icp messaging flows via the zmq-receiver proxy. These are things that *just work* under a tox environment and don't require any special setup. This will be supplemented with good devstack support and full tempest gate, but lets start from the bottom up please! The work that's been done so far allows us to move forward with bug fixing and re-factoring that's backed up on having a base level of unit/functional tests. - -- James Page Ubuntu and Debian Developer james.p...@ubuntu.com jamesp...@debian.org -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1 iQIcBAEBCAAGBQJUajaZAAoJEL/srsug59jDm2wP/1xW99gc/63CXnNowJLwgCAK AflhWs4SAUSF0VizOFoys6j1ApjAwWDG33B927REH/YDNwmAd7PgHRilgcaBjR5w pgaPRctCHPpWtJCWRCAmgkogqJotN3gTDKORxRNaWo9otzjQQbyPP5sEzuLl86/8 0n9KjwhjdJV42fcoKYvWt18uvz9yVOQLlPqj0WhAuzfpeP/5ZkXkd/dOvh6rwJnk wc+ZExPBhdeMNwaJFPZvle++Ki6tZCV8P8+Be5rqTZxdnGxoct72YnIohW48E9Nu 1sjdJCg42vxIMZi8NfkJDDfTBWzOmkab2jcViIJd9ycTn8CT/e62ZK8nN/hnIjla qU8pdRxNkY7xY3AuVoTWYRZGAon+Pp6Xw3J+lh7xUYukKtP/PaN+PjLCmVYrfca0 JQnc8N5bLfcZkz/tx8R09hxqV7cpaRZh/lM6D62XEMRQJ7y9rcUIaJQnHbsmqLw9 lwriXjNE/77eyttQlGnItyBZrTFjCFED9zg6ihK5w0DNXQr3CbIvlgCjiWkXfxDD 1QK05SbsukSlnO+Aqfs/HNICMdiZmqxcqcUcVs/XnKXf5Bi/Y/P0haLb43nFoa3E FaOYvY/T5HSJDvrFK6+kzPgT2zF3sWy4bZjRwKLl8GM8Mm7K65nfd5APhVCnQq5X yZOvpJehduiy6W/lQgzk =HAiM -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- _______________________________________________ OpenStack-dev mailing list OpenStackfirstname.lastname@example.org http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-dev