-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA512 On 02/12/2016 02:41 PM, Andrew Laski wrote:
>> I think if the point of the experience for this API is to be >> working out >>> of the box. So I very much like the idea of a defaults change >>> here to the thing we want to be easy. And an explicit option to >>> disable it if you want to do something more complicated. > I think this creates a potential for confusing behavior for users. > They're happily booting instances with no network on 2.1, as silly > as that might be, and then decide "ooh I'd like to use fancy new > flag foo which is available in 2.35". So they add the flag to their > request and set the version to 2.35 and suddenly multiple things > change about their boot process because they missed that 2.24(or > whatever) changed a default behavior. If this fits within the scope > of microversions then users will need to expect that, but it's > something that would be likely to trip me up as a user of the API. I agree - that's always been the trade-off with microversions. You never get surprises, but you can't move to a new feature in 2.X without also having to get everything that was also introduced in 2.X-1 and before. The benefit, of course, is that the user will have changed something explicitly before getting the new behavior, and at least has a chance of figuring it out. - -- - -- Ed Leafe -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v2 Comment: GPGTools - https://gpgtools.org Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://www.enigmail.net/ iQIcBAEBCgAGBQJWvkXeAAoJEKMgtcocwZqLdEwP/R36392zeHL55LR19ewoSg8/ U9MJEmZo2RiWaJBqWlRsBF5DSNzi7oNzhot8bOcY+aO7XQAs2kfG1QF9YMj/YfTw iqsCtKNfdJZR1lNtq7u/TodkkFLP7gO8Q36efOYvAMIIlZlOoMAyvLWRxDGTGN+t ahgnw2z6oQDpARb6Yx7NFjogjccTENdkuDNyLy/hmuUpvLyvhUDQC1EouVNHPglA Sb8tQYSsdKDHrggs8b3XuJZjJXYvn0M4Knnw3i/0DAVoZamVfsnHJ1EWRfOh7hq3 +C+MJfzfyz5K46ikvjpuSGPPZ8rPPLR1gaih/W2fmXdvKG7NSK3sIUcgJZ7lm4rh VpVDCRWi9rlPuJa4JIKlZ8h6NNMHwiEq8Ea+dP7lHnx0qp8EIxkPDBdU6sCmeUGM tqBeHjUU7f8/fbZkOdorn1NAEZfXcRew3/BeFFxrmu6X8Z2XHHXMBBtlmehEoDHO 6/BzZH3I/5VPcvFZQfsYYivBj3vtmB8cVLbUNpD3xBLyJKVFEwfmGkkYQTlL0KDx B+bqNDw2pK72/qN39rjmdZY/cZ4vGfBGu2CzJxbX+Zn2E8Mgg5rAuARG0OCNg9ll uuVBy37vbPNrNV9UZSkSjmRma/l8kl1IzBbszH0ENbH/ov3ngKB0xWiLc1pBZKC9 GcPgzIoclwLrVooRqOSf =Dqga -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- __________________________________________________________________________ OpenStack Development Mailing List (not for usage questions) Unsubscribe: openstack-dev-requ...@lists.openstack.org?subject:unsubscribe http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-dev
