Thanks Yolanda, this would help me a lot. The transcript is attached. Ifat.
> -----Original Message----- > From: Yolanda Robla Mota [mailto:[email protected]] > Sent: Thursday, December 10, 2015 9:58 AM > To: AFEK, Ifat (Ifat); OpenStack Infra > Subject: Re: [OpenStack-Infra] [vitrage] OpenStack bot quit in the > middle of an IRC meeting > > Hi Ifat > So if you have the transcript, please send it to me, and i can add it > to the site. > Best > Yolanda > > El 10/12/15 a las 07:36, AFEK, Ifat (Ifat) escribió: > > Thanks for the explanation Yolanda. > > Given that I have copy-pasted the meeting log, is there a way to > place > > it under http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/vitrage/2015/? (at > > least the log file itself) > > > > Thanks, > > Ifat. > > > >> -----Original Message----- > >> From: Yolanda Robla Mota [mailto:[email protected]] > >> Sent: Wednesday, December 09, 2015 6:03 PM > >> To: OpenStack Infra > >> Subject: Re: [OpenStack-Infra] [vitrage] OpenStack bot quit in the > >> middle of an IRC meeting > >> > >> Hi Ifat > >> So apologies for that. I approved a change in our bots that caused > >> the issue. > >> When I approved the change i looked at schedule, and there was not > >> meeting going on. But change took a bit long to merge, and it landed > >> in the middle of your meeting. > >> > >> Best > >> Yolanda > >> > >>>> Hi, > >>>> During our Vitrage IRC meeting today on #openstack-meeting-3 (9:00 > >> UTC), OpenStack bot quit in the middle, and our meeting was not > >> recorded. In the log you can see: > >> > >>>> ifat_afek #startmeeting vitrage > >>>> 11:00:29 AM openstack Meeting started Wed Dec 9 09:00:27 2015 > >> UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is > >> > >>>> ifat_afek. Information about MeetBot > >> athttp://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. > >>>> 11:00:30 AM openstack Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help > >> #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. > >>>> 11:00:31 AM openstack changed the topic to: (Meeting topic: > >> vitrage) > >>>> 11:00:33 AM openstack The meeting name has been set to 'vitrage' > >>>> .... > >>>> 11:05:47 AM openstackstatus has quit: Remote host closed the > >> connection. > >>>> 11:05:50 AM openstack has quit: Remote host closed the > >> connection. > >>>> .... > >>>> Anything we can do to fix it? > >>>> Thanks, > >>>> Ifat. > >> -- > >> Yolanda Robla Mota > >> Cloud Automation and Distribution Engineer > >> +34 605641639 > >> [email protected] > >> > >> > >> _______________________________________________ > >> OpenStack-Infra mailing list > >> [email protected] > >> http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-infra > > -- > Yolanda Robla Mota > Cloud Automation and Distribution Engineer > +34 605641639 > [email protected]
ifat_afek #startmeeting vitrage 11:00:29 AM openstack Meeting started Wed Dec 9 09:00:27 2015 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is ifat_afek. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 11:00:30 AM openstack Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 11:00:31 AM openstack changed the topic to: (Meeting topic: vitrage) 11:00:33 AM openstack The meeting name has been set to 'vitrage' 11:00:44 AM ifat_afek Hi everyone ? 11:00:50 AM nadav_yakar Hi 11:00:54 AM alexey_weyl Hi :) 11:01:04 AM oetrog joined the channel. 11:01:09 AM idan_hefetz Hi! 11:01:27 AM oetrog is now known as omer_etrog. 11:01:31 AM elisha_r joined the channel. 11:01:31 AM omer_etrog hi 11:01:32 AM yamahata joined the channel. 11:01:37 AM elisha_r hi all 11:01:44 AM aheller Hola all 11:02:18 AM eyalb hi 11:02:30 AM ifat_afek Todays agenda: 11:02:38 AM ifat_afek * Current status and progress from last week 11:02:48 AM ifat_afek * Review action items 11:02:57 AM ifat_afek * Next steps 11:03:06 AM ifat_afek * Open Discussion 11:03:32 AM emalin joined the channel. 11:03:36 AM emalin hi 11:04:19 AM alexpilotti has quit: Ping timeout: 250 seconds. 11:04:54 AM ayah joined the channel. 11:05:08 AM ayah hi 11:05:11 AM amir_gur joined the channel. 11:05:17 AM amir_gur Hi 11:05:25 AM ifat_afek #topic Current status and progress from last week 11:05:28 AM openstack changed the topic to: Current status and progress from last week (Meeting topic: vitrage) 11:05:35 AM Ohad joined the channel. 11:05:41 AM Ohad hi 11:05:47 AM openstackstatus has quit: Remote host closed the connection. 11:05:50 AM openstack has quit: Remote host closed the connection. 11:05:51 AM ifat_afek We exchanged many emails with Ryota Mibu and Julien Danjou regarding Vitrage integration with Aodh 11:06:03 AM ifat_afek It seems like we might have a workaround for creating Vitrage deduced alarms and Nagios alarms in Aodh 11:06:14 AM ^Gal^ joined the channel. 11:06:24 AM ifat_afek I am checking this workaround, and if it works I will update Ceilometer blueprints 11:06:31 AM openstack joined the channel. 11:06:31 AM ChanServ gave channel operator status to openstack. 11:06:42 AM lhartal joined the channel. 11:06:49 AM ifat_afek #action ifat_afek check Aodh integration workaround and update Ceilometer blueprints 11:07:03 AM ifat_afek Eyal wrote a blueprint for the integration with Monasca, and I asked Roland Hochmuth to review it 11:07:05 AM openstackstatus joined the channel. 11:07:05 AM ChanServ gave voice to openstackstatus. 11:07:22 AM ifat_afek Ohad and I attended PinPoint first IRC meeting 11:07:34 AM ifat_afek They updated their specification documents, and in their next meeting they plan to go over their use cases 11:07:47 AM ifat_afek Here is the link, if you want to review their use cases: 11:07:57 AM ifat_afek #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/projects/pinpoint 11:08:12 AM nadav_yakar has quit: Quit: AndroIRC - Android IRC Client ( http://www.androirc.com ) 11:08:16 AM ifat_afek Last thing: gerrit upgrade is planned for 16/12 from 17:00 UTC, so gerrit might be down for a few hours 11:08:21 AM nadav_yakar joined the channel. 11:09:45 AM Ohad we pretty aligned with PinPoint use cases and we need to further deep dive into each use case in next meetings. 11:10:01 AM nadav_yakar_ joined the channel. 11:10:19 AM calbers joined the channel. 11:10:35 AM ifat_afek anyone wants to update? 11:10:43 AM lhartal yes 11:10:52 AM lhartal We had a meeting where we discussed on the next RCA use case 11:11:10 AM lhartal At the end of the meeting, it was decided that after we finish the entity graph initialization and expose the show topology API, we want to start working on the Vitrage Evaluator as infrastructure for the RCA and Deduced Alarms 11:11:28 AM lhartal We have not decided yet which use cases we will add next and we scheduled a meeting for next week 11:12:14 AM alexey_weyl Due to that meeting we also updated our architecture 11:12:46 AM nadav_yakar has quit: Ping timeout: 252 seconds. 11:13:08 AM nadav_yakar_ left the channel. 11:13:35 AM amir_gur x 11:13:45 AM nadav_yakar joined the channel. 11:14:50 AM nadav_yakar we have contiued our research on how to implement multi-concurrency best on vitrage and its implications on its memory usage 11:15:09 AM yamahata has quit: Ping timeout: 250 seconds. 11:15:26 AM e0ne has quit: Quit: My MacBook Pro has gone to sleep. ZZZzzz 11:16:16 AM nadav_yakar I have also written a basic FW for synchronizer plugin running, which gets a snapshot of all the VMs from a nova service, sends them to a queue, 11:16:43 AM nadav_yakar and a sample for a client which reads from this queue 11:17:01 AM ifat_afek great, thanks 11:17:05 AM ifat_afek any other updates? 11:17:50 AM aheller yes 11:18:13 AM elisha_r I've added a first-round of support for mock synchronizer data, which supports random events which are configurable with a config file 11:18:38 AM elisha_r I plan on enhancing the features of this mock in the coming week 11:18:56 AM ifat_afek cool. aheller? 11:19:12 AM aheller The UI team had user experience session with Anna. 11:19:22 AM alexey_weyl Thanks Elista! already using it :) 11:19:36 AM alexey_weyl *Elisha 11:19:46 AM aheller We sent her our feedback, and the process is still going on 11:20:02 AM aheller That's all 11:20:05 AM ^Gal^ looks awesome 11:20:24 AM ifat_afek I also saw the UI, it looks great!! 11:20:45 AM ifat_afek ^Gal^, any updates on your side? 11:20:46 AM eyalb who is Anna ? 11:21:02 AM ^Gal^ yeah, 11:21:17 AM emalin *aheller* big like ! 11:21:27 AM aheller eyalb: Anna - our special UX person 11:21:41 AM ^Gal^ There hasn't been a commit yet to the Alarms Blueprint on Horizon 11:22:14 AM eyalb awesome 11:22:35 AM ^Gal^ I have some minor UI comments for that spec 11:22:47 AM ^Gal^ I mean the Horizon Alarm spec 11:22:56 AM ^Gal^ but overall it looks great 11:23:07 AM ifat_afek did you send the comments to the guy who implements it? 11:23:54 AM obondarev has quit: Remote host closed the connection. 11:23:55 AM ^Gal^ Haven't yet, I beleive it will be developed in the future due to it complexty 11:24:17 AM ^Gal^ I know you have your remarks regarding the implementation 11:24:25 AM ^Gal^ thought maybe will write it together 11:24:30 AM ^Gal^ we'll* 11:24:43 AM ^Gal^ let's meet and talk 11:25:38 AM danoffek joined the channel. 11:25:39 AM ^Gal^ we could have it all written in one document IMO 11:25:41 AM ifat_afek my remarks are not UX. The blueprint defines two tabs: alarms management and alarms history. The history is more or less ok, but the management does not match our needs. 11:26:05 AM ^Gal^ yeah, agree 11:26:09 AM ifat_afek I'm not sure if we should comment on the alarm management, as it matches the current aodh interface. and we are going to workaournd this interface... 11:26:20 AM ^Gal^ ok 11:26:22 AM ^Gal^ sounds good 11:26:25 AM ifat_afek so we might use only the alarms history, or maybe write our own list-alarms UI 11:26:33 AM ifat_afek we still need to discuss it... 11:26:41 AM ^Gal^ yep let's do 11:26:45 AM ^Gal^ thanks! 11:26:55 AM ifat_afek #decide how to implement list alarms UI 11:27:00 AM ifat_afek I meant: 11:27:11 AM ifat_afek #action decide how to implement list alarms UI 11:27:16 AM ifat_afek let's move on 11:27:23 AM ayah hopefully on wednesday we will have an approvement for our project request for puppet-vitrage 11:27:27 AM ayah than we can start to work on the puppet installation 11:27:39 AM ifat_afek great 11:27:57 AM eyalb *ayah* cool 11:28:00 AM idan_hefetz The graph CRUD for NetworkX is already in, currently working on vertex/edge filtering and testing. 11:28:08 AM idan_hefetz next step is to add the BFS/DFS and sub graph matching. 11:28:25 AM ifat_afek cool 11:28:36 AM eyalb I wrote the monasca integration blueprint 11:28:52 AM eyalb wrote two ways of integration 11:29:13 AM eyalb need to consult with the monasca folx 11:29:25 AM lhartal I wrote the Nova Entity Transformer bluprint 11:29:37 AM eyalb still working on the client and api service 11:29:46 AM ifat_afek lhartal: great, thanks 11:29:54 AM eyalb thats all 11:30:17 AM ifat_afek thanks 11:31:43 AM elisha_r idan_hefetz: regarding the BFS/DFS, we will need to ensure it can take as a parameter also filters on the edge labels. This will be important for the API responses our UI will require. Also, will need to return BFS/DFS with and without edges (I think) 11:32:41 AM idan_hefetz elisha_r: We will, thanks! 11:32:46 AM vgridnev joined the channel. 11:33:08 AM ifat_afek thanks 11:33:11 AM ifat_afek let's move on 11:33:13 AM ifat_afek #topic Review action items 11:33:26 AM ifat_afek ifat continue discussion our alarms with AODH 11:33:31 AM ifat_afek in progress... 11:33:40 AM ifat_afek we are about to create a new project for puppet-vitrage any input for that we will be welcome 11:33:49 AM ifat_afek ifat check if there should be a blueprint for vitrage puppet 11:34:20 AM ayah already update about it. 11:34:32 AM ifat_afek ^Gal^ check again the status of ceilometer UI blueprint, and comment on the whiteboard 11:34:41 AM ifat_afek ^Gal^ already updated too 11:34:50 AM ifat_afek eyalb write a blueprint for monasca integration 11:35:10 AM eyalb already update 11:35:15 AM ifat_afek start discussing the tempest tests 11:35:26 AM ifat_afek Postponed since Eliran was sick. We will do it next week. 11:35:37 AM ifat_afek #action start discussing the tempest tests 11:35:51 AM ifat_afek #topic Next Steps 11:35:57 AM mbound_ joined the channel. 11:37:01 AM elisha_r I think that we are now at a position where we have a good idea of what we expect the UI/API to show, and it's important we align this with the algorithmic capabilities of our graph interation 11:37:02 AM nadav_yakar #action: finalize synchronizer design 11:37:32 AM elisha_r the comment above, about BFS filtering, is just one such example. 11:38:00 AM ayah *hot update* we got an approve our request for puppet-vitrage 11:38:36 AM ifat_afek yay!!! 11:38:38 AM igordcard joined the channel. 11:38:43 AM elisha_r this also impacts what types of queries the API should support, what language to use to express these queries, and how to support the query over NetworkX 11:39:14 AM ayah #action: create puppet-vitrage project (maty) 11:39:47 AM ifat_afek elisha_r: so you are saying it's time we define an end-to-end flow that verifies all our layers work well with each other 11:41:20 AM elisha_r not all the layers. Given we have an updated entity graph, we need an end-to-end flow from API request to response. 11:41:36 AM davidsha joined the channel. 11:41:41 AM matrohon has quit: Ping timeout: 246 seconds. 11:41:45 AM elisha_r for the "show entity graph" and "show network topology" apis, for example, as well as RCA 11:42:12 AM ifat_afek right 11:42:21 AM neiljerram joined the channel. 11:43:33 AM nadav_yakar #action: checkin a basic synchronizer FW for the vitrage graph to interface with and see that we are on the same page 11:43:57 AM elisha_r #action elisha_r end-to-end API flow for the first use cases 11:44:19 AM ifat_afek ok 11:44:21 AM ifat_afek next 11:44:25 AM alexpilotti joined the channel. 11:44:31 AM ifat_afek #topic Open Discussion 11:44:44 AM ifat_afek anything? 11:45:02 AM ifat_afek ok, thanks, everybody. see you next week 11:45:06 AM ifat_afek #endmeeting 11:45:07 AM eyalb bye 11:45:24 AM ayah bye 11:45:29 AM aheller bye 11:45:55 AM omer_etr_ joined the channel. 11:46:44 AM elisha_r has quit: Quit: Page closed. 11:46:47 AM emalin bye 11:47:20 AM danoffek bye 11:47:24 AM ifat_afek #endmeeting
_______________________________________________ OpenStack-Infra mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-infra
