On Thursday 06 October 2005  4:10 pm, Carl-Daniel Hailfinger wrote:
> Simon Dales schrieb:
> > On Thursday 06 October 2005  2:38 pm, Bruce Smith wrote:
> >>>>>>* 10.0-OSS - the Open Source (OSS) version (available from
> >>>>>
> >>>>>ftp.opensuse.org <http://ftp.opensuse.org> and its mirrors):
> >>>>
> >>>>* 10.0 - the retail and Eval versions including some non-OSS software
> >>>>
> >>>>>(available from ftp.suse.com <http://ftp.suse.com> and its mirrors):
> >>
> >>Can you explain the differences between the two, and how they differ
> >>from the boxed-set/purchased version, while you're at it?
> >>
> >>Also, how does the "EVAL" version fit?
> >
> > If Novell/Suse actually belive in open source, then there should be just
> > two versions: one with some closed source added (acroread etc) and one
> > completely open source. Otherwise the method of delivery and support
> > levels should make no difference to the version.
>
> Did I understand you correctly: "If Novell/SUSE believe in open source,
> they will limit our choice"?

No, what I meant is that the boxed version, as I understand it, has some 
closed source/commercial software, such as acroread. A true OSS version would 
exclude these items.

What I object to is "eval" versions. What we want is a choice of fully open 
source and OSS + some commercal.

> > So whether we buy a boxed Suse 10.0 with support or download the CDs/DVDs
> > the bytes (MD5) should be identical. Clearly the actual difference would
> > be whether we got the added value services such as dead trees or phone
> > support.
>
> The RPMs are binary identical. So what exactly is your problem?

But before you get to see the RPMs you need to pick a set of ISOs to 
download. A dowload such as "fred-10.0-Eval-CD1.iso" leads one to suspect 
that even more has been removed than may actually have been. So clarity in 
naming would be a good idea. E.g. "fred-10.0-OSS-CD1.iso" and 
"fred-10.0-OSS-with -commercial-CD1.iso"

-- 
Simon Dales, Software Consultant
"The impossible is easy"

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to