On Sunday 09 October 2005 09:41, nordi wrote:
> When you see this as being insecure, what about GRUB not being password
<snippage>

Hi Nordi,

In my mind, the question was "Should the use of auto login be encouraged or 
suggested?" *not* "Does disabling auto login create a secure computer?"

Password protecting the desktop helps to prevent casual or opportunistic 
snooping and attacks. Access to documents and frequently used "private" 
applications like IM, chat, VOIP and e-mail clients, also one's reading 
material and playlists or financial correspondence, etc., is made more 
difficult... obviously, not impossible... but the front door won't always 
swing wide open and invite such mischief, which is the main concern I have 
with auto login.

Mind you, casual events aren't always "trivial," either They can range from 
jokes gone awry, like someone posing as you sending a dirty joke to your 
spouse but cc's the CEO or the Chief of Police or the Mayor... or someone 
more vengeful sending threats to your Ex or downloading illegal content 
or attempting to destroy your data. Anticipating, and guarding against, such 
potentialities is everybody's responsibility, including Novell/SUSE's.

You and I and others experienced in such matters know enough to uncheck that 
little box during installation. My concern is that it conveys an impression 
to new and unsophisticated customers that auto login is a normal and accepted 
practice within the Linux community, which my belief is it *is not* 
(emphasized for clarity).

Also, leading starts with behavior. If you convey, through your actions as 
well as words, a consistent philosophy and attention to detail, people 
witnessing or participating in some way with you are more likely to follow 
suit. If your actions are contradictory (for instance, seeming to recommend 
auto login during the installation process,) others... particularly those who 
are naive and inexperienced, can be discouraged from making the right 
decision. IMHO, the "right" decision is auto login disabled.

regards,

- Carl

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to