On Wed, 8 Feb 2006, Boyd Lynn Gerber wrote:

> > We should probably delay the redirection on download.openSUSE.org and 
> > have the user browse the local ftp tree and only redirect on file 
> > request, to make sure he can take all files that are available into 
> > account. ATM d.o.o redirects as early as possible, i.e. if you access 
> > http://d.o.o/somepath it will redirect you to a server that has the 
> > path. But that server might not have all the files that are actually 
> > available...
> 
> Yes, sometimes the server only has some or a subset of what is needed 
> for doing a YaST inst.  I was trying to do an internet installation 
> using a user.sel file as a starting point.  I had over 20 packages that 
> could not be installed because the were not on the server I was directed 
> to.  I have noticed on some upgrades that the files are unavailable as 
> well.

So you didn't use download.openSUSE.org as your installation source, but 
used download.openSUSE.org to find a mirror and than c&p'ed it to be the 
installation source. Right? [If you had used download.openSUSE.org all the 
way, it should have choosen different mirrors for different files, because 
it has a local cache where it stores all the information about the status 
of all files on all servers.]

To the server admins: If you feel you don't get enough or too much 
traffic, please contact me (of list), so I can do some fine tuning. ATM 
all request directed at download.openSUSE.org are distributed equally 
amongst our "primary" mirrors.

If there is interest in this topic, I might prepare some slides to give a 
"speed talk" on this at FOSDEM.


> > The inital usecase for d.o.o (when I did the first implementation) was 
> > to have a generic URL for the announcements and to point the installer 
> > (YaST) to. But it actually seems people try to browse the inst-sources 
> > with it -- and end up on mirrors that are not completely in sync -- 
> > right?
> 
> Yes!

Alright, I'll put this onto my agenda...


Regards
        Christoph

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to