Billie Walsh wrote:
On 11/08/2007 Aaron Kulkis wrote:
Doesn't sound like you're told him that SMART *MIGHT* be
giving a bogus report... you told him in no uncertain terms
that without a doubt, his drive is 100% good, and that
SMART is 100% wrong.
SO, JUST GET OFF MY ASS!
When you stop being a jerk, I gladly will.
Here's the ACTUAL quote from my ORIGINAL message, in it's entirety:
strange how "in it's entirety" seems to leave out
what you actually wrote.
Don't know if this helps, but a few years ago I had a computer that was
saying the same thing. I couldn't find anything wrong with the drive so
I turned off smart and used it another couple years before it finally
failed.
I don't think I said anything in particular about HIS drive. I said I
had the problem. There was nothing wrong with MY drive. My inferrence
was that SMART can be wrong.
I never said he shouldn't check his drive. I did check mine.
You didn't tell him to check his drive.
You told him that SMART was wrong, and that the drive was
indisputably good.
I never said his drive was not going to fail. I said that MY drive ran
for another couple years just fine.
When people quit mis-quoting me and reading things in that aren't there
I will be much nicer. I offered a bit of hard earned wisdom. Everyone
immediately jumped my ass about it. I think the actual jerks are the
ones that immediately told him to junk his old drive and buy a new one.
No, here is the ENTIRETY OF YOU ACTUALLY wrote to him (including
his text that you replied to) (Message-ID:
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> :
+ On 11/07/2007 James Knott wrote:
+ + One thing to bear in mind, is that drives have spare sectors,
which get
+ + used as others fail. The warning is to tell you that the drive
is well
+ + on it's way to failing and should be replaced ASAP. You were
lucky that
+ + it didn't fail sooner. What you did, is comparable to disabling the
+ + engine light on a car, rather than fixing what's causing it to
turn on.
+ There was nothing wrong with the drive. There was
+ something in SMART that was wrong. I've seen SMART
+ say that a brand new drive is failing. SMART is
+ nothing like the engine light on a car.
You didn't tell him to check his drive.
You told him that SMART was wrong, and that the drive was
indisputably good.
SO, BITE ME!
You're just gonna keep on digging deeper and deeper,
aren't you, asshole.
--
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
