+1 with Kevan regarding "private communications" this is not got for any "open" source community.
On Tue, Jan 20, 2009 at 8:38 PM, Kevan Miller <[email protected]> wrote: > > On Jan 20, 2009, at 7:07 AM, Mark Struberg wrote: > >> Hi! >> >> As I already tried to expain: it was never ment to use git for productive >> changes - think about it more like a blog full with code ;) > > Understood. However, there are other ways of accomplishing this. Which would > probably be more acceptable... > > 1) create an openwebbeans/sandbox in svn > 2) generate a patch and post to the jira > 3) discuss your intentions/proposed changes (which you've done), and commit > them in trunk. The community should be reviewing all changes. It's not > necessarily bad to discover disagreements, post-commit. These disagreements > can be resolved. > > At Apache, all committers have earned the necessary karma to be fully > trusted. IIUC, this is un-Git like (at least it doesn't match my > understanding of the social norms in Git usage). We may be able to work out > acceptable usage of Git. I want to be sure we're avoiding "private" > communications about code and some usages of Git might lead to the potential > for private conversations. BTW, I'm certainly not implying that this is your > (or anybody else's) intent... > >> >> >> Back to the issue: how do we cope with the TCK code? Should I check it in >> to SVN? It will compile, but cannot run due to API incompatibilities between >> us and RI. But as long as we do not add the <module> in the parent pom it >> will at least not break the build. > > Guess we could add the JBoss snapshot repo to our builds... This would cause > problems during releases and as the TCK changes. > >> >> I will create a Jira and attach the TCK suite via patch in the meantime. > > Personally, I'd commit the changes > >> >> I saw Jukka will organise a GIT session on the ApacheCon EU. Maybe we'll >> find some time there... > > Sounds good. I'm hoping that I can attend, this year... > > --kevan > > -- ---- Thanks - Mohammad Nour - LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.com/in/mnour ---- "Life is like riding a bicycle. To keep your balance you must keep moving" - Albert Einstein
