On 2/16/10 11:47 PM, Olaf Selke wrote: > Roger Dingledine schrieb: >> On Tue, Feb 16, 2010 at 11:21:56PM +0100, Olaf Selke wrote: >>>> The free >>>> maxmind one is intentionally crippled, which makes me not so optimistic >>>> about its future. >>> the free of charge MaxMind's db works perfectly to match the country. >>> Determining state/region, city, US postal code, and so on requires the >>> non crippled version. >> >> Really? I am under the impression that they have four databases: 1) >> crippled (gpl) country db, 2) non-crippled (commercial) country db, 3) >> crippled city db, 4) non-crippled city db. > > here's a comparison between the free of charge (gpl) GeoLite Country and > the commercial GeoIP Country version > http://www.maxmind.com/app/geolitecountry > > Accuracy seems to be 0,3% different and update interval differs. Don't > get me wrong, I'm not trying to convince tor developers to switch over > to MaxMind's product. My intention only has been to understand the > bridge relay startup errors. I was mistaken about the geoip db format > even I rtfm.
My impression is also that free and commercial Maxmind don't differ by that much. I started working on a GeoIP database comparison in October 2009 that might be of interest here: http://freehaven.net/~karsten/metrics/geoipdbcomp-2009-10-23.pdf As you can see in Figure 3, the two Maxmind databases have significant overlap. I didn't investigate any further what the differences are and in how far they affect the countries we're interested in with respect to bridge usage. I'm going to publish the scripts for drawing these graphs in the next few days on http://metrics.torproject.org/. If someone wants to pick this up, I'm happy to help out with support. --Karsten *********************************************************************** To unsubscribe, send an e-mail to [email protected] with unsubscribe or-talk in the body. http://archives.seul.org/or/talk/
