What I don't understand is the loop construction:

Actually only one (row) is read form the cursor, and then the function is left with a return. Because it's an unconditional return, the code within the loop will either execute  once, or never. When no data is found NULL is returned. When an error occurs NULL is returned as well. So, why a loop?

Wouldn't it be better to have something like:

create or replace function XYZ(gid in number) return varchar2 is
  l_c1   tab1.C1%TYPE;    /* local variable to store C1 */
begin
  select c1
  into l_c1
  from    tab1
  where  id = gid;
 
  return  l_c1;

exception
  when no_data_found
    then return <some_error_code>;  /* let the caller know that no data is found */
  when others
    then return 'ERROR: '||TO_CHAR(SQLCODE); /* return the error-code, preceded by the text ERROR for identification */
end;

Sure, a loop prevents an ORA-1422, but I don't think a loop construction should be abused for this. Just think about all loop controlling code that needs to be set up by the interpreter. tab1.ID should be unique, so a 1422 normally cannot occur. Robust programming however asks us to prevent any error. I would prefer to think about how a 1422 should be handled, and write some code accordingly.

Regards, Carel-Jan

===
If you think education is expensive, try ignorance. (Derek Bok)
===


At 09:39 28-12-03 -0800, you wrote:
Hi

if  we assume it is  implements this way (see below) there will only be one cursor since c_gid
is a bind variable and there for the cursor will be sharded from  call to call of the function.

create or replace function XYZ (gid in number) return varchar2 is
  cursor cur1(c_gid number) is select C1 from tab1 where id = c_gid;
begin
  for x in cur1(gid) loop
    return x.c1;
  end loop;
  return null;
exception
  when others then return null;
end;

It will only be one coursor

Guang Mei wrote:

I have a function like below (psudo code). If cursor cur1 have
multiple
rows, would the code leave the cursor open when this function is 
called?
So if this function is called 1000 times, I would have 1000 open
cursors?

function XYZ(gid in number) return varchar2 is
  cursor cur1 is select C1 from tab1 where ID = gid;
begin
  for x in cur1 loop
    return x.c1;
  end loop;
  return null;
exception
  when others then return null;
end;

  

--

Best regards/Venlig hilsen

Peter Gram

Miracle A/S
Kratvej 2
DK - 2760 Måløv
Cell:  (+45) 2527 7107
Phone: (+45) 4466 8855
Fax:   (+45) 4466 8856
Home:  (+45) 3874 5696
Email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to