Thank you for destroying my reputation in the US market. The market will know
the truth of the big picture and the time will tell who did what.
Thank you.
----- Original Message -----
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Friday, October 22, 2004 4:07 AM
Subject: Importing Orchids from SE Asia
Prompted by Lauder's problems in getting delivery from a SE Asian
Nursery, I wish to report a more pleasant experience with Saigon Orchids and
Flora of Viet Nam. Some of the fleshy bulbed species [Calanthe, Phaius, etc.]
I ordered were found to harbor beetle larvae by the supposedly lax Miami Ag
inspectors, and required gassing. Ag took the trouble to point the larvae out
to me so there was no denying them. The Orchid exporters I deal with request
only 50% of the payment up front, permitting holding back a sum for
adjustments, if necessary. I pointed out the problem to Saigon O&F and
suggested an adjustment of 50% value of the three gassed cartons [out of nine]
for delayed injuries. They agreed without dispute. So if one wants SE Asian
orchids, I suggest trying Saigon O&F as honorable.
In contrast, I have obtained a few shipments from Simanis in Indonesia.
The earlier ones contained excellent specimens, but the last shipment was
gassed with dire consequences. This was incontestable since live beetles were
found on the foliage in my presence, as the boxes were opened. When Mr.
Kolopaking, of Simanis bugged me by email for quick settlement because he
needed the money "for his sick mother" I opted for an adjustment of 20%. With
time, the true extent of the damage was closer to 60%. I so informed him and
said that I would expect a further adjustment on the next shipment. I was
prepared to sell his stock at the Redlands Fair [Miami] last May, but I
requested a further allowance for the damage to the previous shipment. He
refused! As a consequence I have not dealt with him since, nor would I take a
chance in the future. When live beetles appear, this is clearly the shipper's
fault since it indicates inadequate treatment for insects.
The moral of the story is that there are reputable orchid dealers in SE
Asia, but some are less reputable than others. Caveat emptor. The second
conclusion is that Miami Ag Inspectors are anything but lax, but they are
willing to take the trouble to point out to the importer the reason that a
given shipment has to be gassed. My conclusion is that they are true
professionals and Kathy's alarm is unwarranted.
Bert Pressman
_______________________________________________
the OrchidGuide Digest (OGD)
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.orchidguide.com/mailman/listinfo/orchids
