In a recent posting, Juli asked about Brassavola nodosa and Brassavola
grandiflora. The following is what my digging has through the literature (at
least what I have available) has turned up concerning the subject.

~Brassavola grandiflora Lindley
AKA: Many authorities consider this species a synonym of Brassavola nodosa
Lindley, or at most, Brassavola nodosa var. grandiflora (Lindley) Jones.

Withner (1996), however, maintains Brassavola grandiflora Lindley as a
separate species and includes the following as synonyms. Bletia nodosa var.
grandiflora (Lindley) Rchb. f., Bletia rhopalorrhachis Rchb. f., Brassavola
nodosa var. grandiflora (Lindley) Jones, Brassavola nodosa var.
rhopalorrhachis Schlechter, Brassavola rhopalorrhachis Rchb. f., Brassavola
scaposa Schlechter.

To further confound and confuse the issue, Ames & Correll (1985) listed the
following synonyms. Brassavola nodoas var. rhopalorrhachis (Rchb. f.)
Schlechter, Brassavola rhopalorrhachis Rchb. f., Brassavola venosa Lindley,
Epidendrum nodosum Linnaeus as synonyms of Brassavola nodosa (Linnaeus)
Lindley.

Hamer (1982), however, treated Brassavola grandiflora Lindley as a separate
species but listed only Brassavola nodosa var. grandiflora (Lindley) Jones
as a synonym.

On the other hand, Williams and Allen (1980) included Brassavola scaposa
Schlechter, Brassavola venosa LIndley, and Epidendrum nodosum Linnaeus as
synonyms of Brassavola nodosa (Linnaeus) Lindley.

The most recent work appears to consider them as separate species. As near
as I can determine, however, they apparantly differ primarily only in size,
but some writers indicate that Brassavola grandiflora differs from
Brassavola nodosa by having broader, flattened leaves and a spotless white
lip.


_______________________________________________
the OrchidGuide Digest (OGD)
[email protected]
http://orchidguide.com/mailman/listinfo/orchids_orchidguide.com

Reply via email to