K Barrett asked: "I understand Cirropetalums have been moved back to Bulbophyllum. Is that so? And who was the taxonomic authority who moved them and how accepted was the change? The reason I ask is because I have Sigreist's book, ....."
Kathy, I hope you're not hoping to trigger-off a flame-session, because questions like this can lead to vitriolic arguments. The answer to your Q is that no taxonomic authority moved Cirrhopetalum back to Bulbophyllum. The transfer isn't necessary. You asked the wrong question. In my opinion, you would have done better to question the taxonomic authority of those who tried to separate Cirrhopetalum from Bulbophyllum in the first place. And therein lies a long and convoluted story. I'll try to shorten it. Both Bulbophyllum and Cirrhopetalum are very old names; Bulbophyllum was established by Thouars in 1822, Cirrhopetalum by Lindley in 1824. Initially, it was easy to keep the two genera separate, but as more and more species were added, it became clear that separation could not be maintained, and the two genera were merged. At this point, Cirrhopetalum (being the younger name) was reduced either to a synonym of Bulbophyllum, or (more usually) to a section inside Bulbophyllum, or (sometimes) to a subgenus under Bulbophyllum. There have been repeated attempts to re-establish Cirrhopetalum as a genus. They have all failed in the long run. In some highly authoritative cases (like Rudolph Schlechter), the author(s) initially treated Cirrhopetalum as a genus, but as they became more familiar with the range of species that need to be taken into consideration, reluctantly abandoned the concept of a "genus" Cirrhopetalum and switched to using Bulbophyllum instead. For a long, long time the consensus amongst knowledgable orchidologists has been that you cannot separate Cirrhopetalum from Bulbophyllum on the basis of morphological characters. In 1994, Garay, Siegerist et al attempted (yet another) division of the Bulbophyllinae, based upon purely morphological characters. Amongst other proposals, they resurrected Cirrhopetalum as a genus, and created several minor genera such as Mastigion. I was not impressed by their arguments (don't ask ... my reasons are very lengthy) and I decided that it was more accurate to stick to the old-fashioned concept of Bulbophyllum. 13 years later on, I'm certain I made the correct decision. There is a clear consensus amongst recent authors ... how many use Mastigion, Rhytionanthos, etc ? And how many use Bulbophyllum ? So my answer to your question is that no taxonomic authority has moved Cirrhopetalum back to Bulbophyllum, because they were never satisfactorially separated in the first place. Peter O'Byrne _______________________________________________ the OrchidGuide Digest (OGD) [email protected] http://orchidguide.com/mailman/listinfo/orchids_orchidguide.com

